Pens for hire: Part 2
DOI :
https://doi.org/10.11575/cpai.v5i1.75420Mots-clés :
academic fraud, contract cheating, ghost writing, history, term paper millsRésumé
This is part two of a three part invited article series examining the historical evolution of the contract cheating industry. As far back as the aftermath of the First World War there were small commercial operators serving the wants of students who preferred to purchase essays rather than write them. Occasionally, as described in part one of this series, these were exposed by journalists and once even taken to court by local authorities. By the end of the turbulent 1960s, however, those businesses had emerged from the shadows and were aggressively advertising their wares. In response, universities and government entities made more determined attempts to suppress the trade. This article focuses on the attempts of three jurisdictions to shut down the term paper mills: New York, Wisconsin, and Massachusetts. Part two concludes with a series of questions to encourage reflection and discussion with students or educators and practitioners.
Références
Atkins, N. (1987, March 26). Fast food for thought: A brief history of cliffs notes and the man who made synopsizing texts synonymous with his name. Rolling Stone, 160.
Badger Herald. (1972, February). Term Paper Hawkers Sued in NY. Badger Herald, 3.
Bartel, R. (1973, November). ‘Outlaw’ term paper mills survive. Badger Herald, 1.
Begalke, N. J. (1972, February 20). U. eyes court action against ‘Term Paper Mills.’ Capital Times1.
Beggs, D. C., & Copeland, H. A. (1972, April 6). Most Students Say ‘No” to Ghost-written Term Papers. Wisconsin State Journal.
Branagan, B. (1972, April 25). Termpaper mills flunk out. Daily Cardinal, 2.
Capital Times. (1973, February 10). Committee rejects bill on term paper fines. Capital Times.
Cartwright, J. (1961, June 24). Those ‘crib notes.’ Ottawa Journal.
Daily Cardinal. (1972, June 16). Classified advertisement by Educational Research, Inc. Daily Cardinal.
Department of Agriculture, T. and C. P. D. (1972). Press release 192/10-17-72 from the office of the Attorney General, Department of Justice, State of Wisconsin. State Historical Society of Wisconsin Archives, Series 758, Box 42.
Dresser, J. (1972, September 8). Termpaper discipline on individual basis. Daily Cardinal, 8.
Dunford, G. (1966, March 8). Teachers take to ‘bumblebee’ writing. Toronto Star.
Eggert, J. R. (1972, October 21). U.S. Seeks Ban On Mailings Of Termpapers. The Harvard Crimson, 1, 4.
Flegel, R. (1972, July 4). Buying term papers doesn’t make the grade. Wisconsin State Journal.
House Bill No. 6538. House document number 6980., (1973) (testimony of Governor Francis W. Sargent to the Senate and House of Representatives of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts).
Gray, C. (1977, March 6). Life in a term-paper factory. New York Times, 30.
Green Bay Press-Gazette. (1972a, February 22). UW keeps tabs on term paper suit (AP report). Green Bay Press-Gazette.
Green Bay Press-Gazette. (1972b, May 18). UW silence on cheating (editorial). Green Bay Press-Gazette.
Green Bay Press-Gazette. (1972c, June 14). The fake essay story (editorial). Green Bay Press-Gazette.
Greenberg, P. (1972). Wanna buy a better grade, Kid? Wisconsin Alumnus, 11–12.
Gribble, R. A. (1972, May 5). Cheating at UW: A concern, but not major problem. Wisconsin State Journal.
Hechinger, F. M. (1972, March 17). Term papers: Passing grades for a price. New York Times.
Heinberg, N. (1972, June 8). Term paper seller saw no problem of ethics, he testifies. Capital Times.
Hill, J. (1972, May). Term paper mills under legal eye. Badger Herald, 11–14.
Humphreys, T. S. (1972, March 6). Term papers for sale: A consumer’s test. Chronicle of Higher Education.
Johnson, D. (1972a, May 19). Termpaper customers face dual sanctions, says Dean. Daily Cardinal, 2.
Johnson, D. (1972b, June 16). Termpaper firms give up, go home. Daily Cardinal, 2.
No. 91, 29th Legislature, Second Session, 3651, (testimony of Legislature of Ontario Debates).
Linton, M. (1988, May 22). Take note: Exam time’s cram time. (Toronto) Sunday Sun, C11.
Maeroff, G. L. (1971, July 10). Market in term papers is booming. New York Times, 25.
McBride, J. (1972, February 28). Termiknowledgey: Or, how to become a millionaire--fast. Wisconsin State Journal.
Mentzer, M. (1972a, June). Termpapers from boom to bust. Badger Herald, 3.
Mentzer, M. (1972b, August). Dean Ginsberg reflects on term paper problem. Badger Herald.
Middlebrook, S. (1961, April 9). No panacea for college cheating. New York Times, 17.
Muir, K. (1971, November 17). Plagiarism: Only for the lazy? The Varsity, 6–7.
Murphy, P. (1973, May 4). It’s write on, for UW students, while term paper business flops. Wisconsin State Journal, 1–2.
New York State Education Law, Section 213-b.1, (1972).
New York Times. (1973, May 6). Concerns that sell ‘research’ to students are under attack. New York Times, New Jersey Section.
New York Times. (1975, April 13). Unheadlined paragraph. New York Times, 20.
Research Assistance Catalog 24 (p. 1). (1994).
Segall, C. (1972). Student standpoint: Term paper mills vs. term paper rituals. Wisconsin Alumnus, 12.
Sentinel, M. (1972, April 19). Court orders term papers sale halt. Milwaukee Sentinel.
Sirica, J. (n.d.). Knight-Ridder News Service, “Cliffs Notes: A long look at shortcuts.” Miami Herald.
State of Wisconsin Department of Agriculture. (1972). Docket No. 997, 11 October 1972. State Historical Society of Wisconsin Archives, series 758, box 42: Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection Division, Correspondence and Subject File 1927-1974,.
Suffolk Superior Court. (1972a, October 19). Trustees of Boston University v. Champion Research Corp., et al, Equity No. 96114, Bill for Declaratory Judgment. 3.
Suffolk Superior Court. (1972b, November 9). Trustees of Boston University v. Champion Research Corp., et al., Equity No. 96114, document 14.
Supreme Court of New York, Special Term, New York County, 69 Misc. 2d 554; 332 N.Y.S.2d 343; 1972 N.Y. Misc. (1972). State of New York v. Kathleen Saksniit et al., ., 18 April 1972.
Swain, B. (1972a, May 17). Complaint Tells Story Of Term Paper Mill. Capital Times.
Swain, B. (1972b, May 18). Some may get, then lose degrees. Capital Times.
Swain, B. (1972c, December 23). Fate of 64 UW Term Paper Purchasers Still Up in Air. Capital Times.
The Harvard Crimson. (1972, October 25). Steve Roper comic strip sparks $6 million lawsuit. The Harvard Crimson, 1.
Time. (1972, March 27). Crackdown on Fakes. Time.
Equity No. 96114, document 32, Motion to Revoke Order of Sequestration, (1973) (testimony of et al Trustees of Boston University v. Champion Research Corp.).
F.Supp. 76, Civ. A. No. 72-3225, United States District Court, D. Massachusetts, (1972) (testimony of et al United States of America and United States Postal Service v. International Term Papers, Inc.).
F.2d 1277, United State Court of Appeals, First District, heard 5 March 1973, decided 3 May 1973, (1973) (testimony of et al. United States of America and United States Postal Service v. International Term Papers).
University of Wisconsin—Madison Archives. (1972). Memorandum from Ginsberg to Academic Deans at UW—M dated 25 May 1972. Series 40/1/15/1, box 9. Central Administration, Senior Legal Counsel, Student Discipline.
University of Wisconsin. (1972, May 1). University of Wisconsin—Madison Faculty Document 99. University of Wisconsin—Madison Faculty Document 99.
Waalkes, J. (1973, October 16). Term papers keep coming, but not for long. Daily Cardinal, 1.
Waggnoner, W. H. (1972a, February 11). State acts to outlaw companies selling theses. New York Times, 46.
Waggnoner, W. H. (1972b, February 13). 23 term papers sold after theft; Concern in Queens to give them back to Harvard. New York Times.
Wisconsin Alumnus. (1973, January). Dean gives report on punishments for term paper purchasers. Wisconsin Alumnus, 16–17.
Wisconsin State Journal. (1972, May 10). State will start inquiry into sale of term papers. Wisconsin State Journal.
Wisniewski, S. (1971, October 26). Now profs write papers for students. Daily Cardinal, 1.
