What is the Role of Trust in Peer Support Schemes for Underrepresented Students?

Claire Hamshire; Mimi Benjamin; Alan Soong Swee Kit

doi:10.20343/teachlearninqu.13.8

Authors

Claire Hamshire University of Salford https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8585-2207
Mimi Benjamin Indiana University of Pennsylvania
Alan Soong Swee Kit National University of Singapore

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.20343/teachlearninqu.13.8

Keywords:

belonging, trust, social connection, peer support, underrepresented

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to explore how peer support schemes can be used to facilitate meaningful relationships and a sense of belonging for underrepresented students. Using three case studies, the study explored and compared peer support leaders’ narratives about their experiences at three universities: one in the United Kingdom (UK), one in the United States (USA), and the other in Singapore. One-to-one interviews and focus groups were completed with 25 students (15 in the UK, four in the USA, and six in Singapore) to explore their perceptions and experiences of being a peer support lead within their institution. These three case studies (one at each institution) explore the multifaceted concept of belonging in order to identify the relative influences of social connection, shared culture/experiences and interpersonal trust. The results demonstrated that the students were aware of the challenges faced by underrepresented students and how peer support schemes can facilitate belonging. Whilst the three settings are diverse, the findings demonstrate that supporting learning transitions and the navigation of liminal spaces through peer support can encourage trust, belonging, and student success. We propose a conceptual model for considering how social connection, shared culture/experiences, and interpersonal trust can contribute to the central goal of belonging. This conceptual model can be used as a resource to support consideration of peer support schemes for underrepresented students that can be developed to support student belonging.

Author Biographies

Claire Hamshire, University of Salford

Dr. Claire Hamshire (GBR) is the associate pro vice-chancellor, education and student experience at the University of Salford, and a professor of higher education.

Mimi Benjamin, Indiana University of Pennsylvania

Dr. Mimi Benjamin (USA) is a professor of student affairs in higher education at Indiana University of Pennsylvania.

Alan Soong Swee Kit, National University of Singapore

Alan Soong Swee Kit (SGP) is the former associate director at the Centre for Development of Teaching and Learning and resident fellow at Prince George’s Park House at the National University of Singapore.

References

Allen, Kelly-Ann, Margaret L. Kern, Christopher S. Rozek, Dennis M. McInerney, and George M. Slavich. 2021. “Belonging: A Review of Conceptual Issues, An Integrative Framework, And Directions For Future Research.” Australian Journal of Psychology 73 (1): 87–102. https://doi.org/10.1080/00049530.2021.1883409.

Bauer, Paul C., and Markus Freitag. 2018. “Measuring Trust.” In The Oxford Handbook of Social and Political Trust, edited by Eric M. Uslaner, 15–36. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Bear, Stephen, and Gwen Jones. 2017. “Students as Protégés: Factors that Lead to Success.” Journal of Management Education 41 (1): 146–68.

Bilham, Tim, Claire Hamshire, Mary Harthog, and Martina A. Doolan. 2019. Reframing Space for Learning: Excellence and Innovation in University Teaching. London: IOE Press.

Bourke, Brian. 2016. “Meaning and Implications of Being Labelled a Predominantly Whie Institution.” College & University 91 (3): 13-21.

Carey, Matthew C., Anna Chick, Bridie Kent, and Jos M. Latour. 2018. “An Exploration of Peer-Assisted Learning in Undergraduate Nursing Students in Pediatric Clinical Settings: An Ethnographic Study.” Nurse Education Today 1 (65): 212–17. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2018.03.014.

Carvalho, Sergio W., and Marcio de Oliveira Mota. 2010. “The Role of Trust in Creating Value and Student Loyalty in Relational Exchanges Between Higher Education Institutions and Their Students.” Journal of Marketing for Higher Education 20 (1): 145–65.

Cole, Darnell, Christopher B. Newman, and Liane I. Hypolite. 2020. “Sense of Belonging Among Two Cohorts of First-Year Students Participating in a Comprehensive College Transition Program.” American Behavioral Scientist 64 (3): 276–97. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764219869417.

Collier, Peter J. 2015. Developing Effective Student Peer Mentoring Programs. Sterling, VA: Stylus.

Cook-Sather, Alison, Peter Felten, Kaylyn (Kayo) Piper Stewart, and Heidi Weston. 2023. “Reviving the Construct of ‘Mattering’ in Pursuit of Equity and Justice in Higher Education: Illustrations from Mentoring and Partnership Programs.” In Academic Belonging in Higher Education, edited by Eréndira Rueda and Candice Lowe Swift, 17. New York: Routledge.

Cureton, Debra and Phil Gravestock. 2019. “‘We Belong’: Differential Sense of Belonging And Its Meaning for Different Ethnic Groups In Higher Education.” Compass: Journal of Learning and Teaching 12 (1).

Delhey, Jan, Kenneth Newton, and Christian Welzel. 2011. “How General Is Trust in ‘Most People’? Solving the Radius of Trust Problem.” American Sociological Review 76 (5): 786–807. https://doi.org/10.1177/0003122411420817.

Elon University Center for Engaged Learning. “High-Impact Practices and Historically Underrepresented Minority Students.” Accessed July 13, 2023. https://www.centerforengagedlearning.org/resources/high-impact-practices-and-historically-underrepresented-minority-students/.

Fischer, Mary J. 2007. “Settling Into Campus Life: Differences by Race/Ethnicity in College Involvement and Outcomes.” The Journal of Higher Education 78 (2): 125–61. https://doi.org/10.1080/00221546.2007.11780871.

Fosnacht, Kevin, and Shannon Calderone. 2020. “Who Do Students Trust? An Exploratory Analysis of Undergraduates’ Social Trust.” [Conference Session]. Presented at the Annual (Virtual) Conference of the Association for the Study of Higher Education. https://scholarworks.iu.edu/dspace/handle/2022/25947.

Forsyth, Rachel, Claire Hamshire, Danny Fontaine-Rainen, and Leza Soldaat. 2022. “Shape-shifting and Pushing Against the Odds: Staff Perceptions of the Experiences of First Generation Students in South Africa and the UK.” The Australian Educational Researcher 49: 307–21. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13384-021-00438-8.

Foxx, Kiana. 2021. “Cultivating a Sense of Belonging: Black Students at a Predominantly White Institution.” The Negro Educational Journal 72 (1–4): 107–29.

Freeman, Tierra M., Lynley Anderman, and Jane M. Jensen. 2007. “Sense of Belonging in College Freshmen at the Classroom and Campus Levels.” The Journal of Experimental Education 75 (3): 203–20. https://doi.org/10.3200/jexe.75.3.203-220.

Gagnon, Jessica Dawn. 2018. “‘Bastard’ Daughters in the Ivory Tower: Illegitimacy and the Higher Education Experiences of the Daughters of Single Mothers in the UK.” Teaching in Higher Education 23 (5): 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1080/13562517.2018.1449743.

Gao, Fang, and Henry Chi Yin Liu. 2021. “Guests in Someone Else’s House? Sense of Belonging Among Ethnic Minority Students in a Hong Kong University.” British Educational Research Journal 47 (4): 1004–20. https://doi.org/10.1002/berg.3704.

Guo, Yuan. 2017. “The Influence of Social Support on the Prosocial Behavior of College Students: The Mediating Effect Based on Interpersonal Trust.” English Language Teaching 10 (12): 158–63.

Hamshire, Claire and Christopher Wibberley. 2017. “Fitting in With the Team: Facilitative Mentors in Physiotherapy Student Placements.” Teaching & Learning Inquiry 5 (2): 80–8. https://doi.org/10.20343/teachlearninqu.5.2.7.

Hamshire, C., Deborah O’Connor, and Kirsten Jack. 2019. “Collaborative and Reflective Spaces for Developing Professional Practitioners.” In Reframing Space for Learning: Excellence and Innovation in University Teaching, edited by Tim Bilham, Claire Hamshire, Mary Hartog, with Martina A. Doolan. London: IOE Press.

Hindle, C., V. Boliver, A. Maclarnon, C. McEwan, B. Simpson, and H. Brown. 2021. “Experiences of First-Generation Scholars at a Highly Selective UK University.” Learning and Teaching 14 (2): 1–31. https://doi.org/10.3167/latiss.2021.140202.

Hussain, Maryam, and James M. Jones. 2021. “Discrimination, Diversity, and Sense of Belonging: Experiences of Students of Color.” Journal of Diversity in Higher Education 14 (1): 63–71. https://doi.org/10.1037/dhe0000117.

Jorgenson, Derek A., Laura C. Farrell, Julie L. Fudge, and Andrew Pritchard. 2018. “College Connectedness: The Student Perspective.” Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning 18 (1): 75–95. https://doi.org/10.14434/josotl.v18i1.22371.

Kahu, Ella R., Nicole Ashley, and Catherine Picton. 2022. “Belonging in Higher Education: Familiarity, Interpersonal and Academic Belonging.” Student Success Journal 13 (2): 10–20. https://doi.org/10:5204/ssj.2264.

Krusemark, Stephanie, and G. White. 2020. “Relationships Drive Success: How Peer Mentoring Empowers Students.” Liberal Education (Winter/Spring): 56–7.

Lim, Lisa-Angelique, Simon Buckingham Shum, Peter Felten, and Jennifer Uno. In Press. “Belonging Analytics: A Proposal.” Learning Letters.

Longfellow Erica, Steve May, Linda Burke, and Diane Marks-Maran. 2008. “‘They Had a Way of Helping That Actually Helped’: A Case Study of a Peer-Assisted Learning Scheme.” Teaching in Higher Education 13 (1): 93–105. https://doi.org/10.1080/13562510701794118.

Maramba, Dina C., and Samuel D. Museus. 2013. “Examining the Effects of Campus Climate, Ethnic Group Cohesion, and Cross-Cultural Interaction on Filipino American Students’ Sense of Belonging.” Journal of College Student Retention 14 (4): 495–522. https://doi.org/10.2190/CS.14.4.d.

Mayer, Roger C., James H. Davis, and F. David Schoorman. 1995. “An Integrative Model of Organizational Trust.” Academy of Management Review 20 (3): 709–34. https://doi.org/10.2307/258792.

McIntyre, Jason C., Joanne Worsley, Rhiannon Corcoran, Paula Harrison Woods, and Richard P. Bentall. 2018. “Academic and Non-Academic Predictors of Student Psychological Distress: The Role of Social Identity and Loneliness.” Journal of Mental Health 27 (3): 230–39. https://doi.org/10.1080/09638237.2018.1437608.

Paredes-Collins, Kristen, and Eric J. McIntosh. 2020. “Thriving and Students of Color: Daily Transitions on Predominantly White Campuses.” In Thriving in Transitions: A Research-Based Approach to College Student Success, edited by Laurie A. Schreiner, Michelle C. Louis, and Denise D. Nelson, 79–96. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina, National Resource Center for the First-Year Experience and Students in Transition.

Pascarella, Ernest T., and Patrick T. Terenzini. 2005. How College Affects Students: A Third Decade of Research (2nd volume). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Pike, Gary R., and George D. Kuh. 2005. “A Typology of Student Engagement for American Colleges and Universities.” Research in Higher Education 46 (2): 185–209. https://doi.org/10.1007/s 11162-004-1599-0.

Pittman, Laura D., and Adeya Richmond. 2008. “University Belonging, Friendship Quality, and Psychological Adjustment During the Transition To College.” The Journal of Experimental Education 76 (4): 343–61. https://doi.org/10.3200/JEXE.76.4.343-362.

Ritchie, Jane, and Liz Spencer. 1994. “Analyzing Qualitative Data.” In Qualitative Data Analysis for Applied Policy Research, edited by Alan Bryman, and Robert G. Burgess, 173-194. London: Routledge.

Ritchie, Jane, and Liz Spencer. 2002. “Qualitative Data Analysis for Applied Policy Research.” In Analyzing Qualitative Data, edited by Alan Bryman, and Robert G. Burgess, 187– 208. London: Routledge.

Rodriguez, Sarah L., and Blaney, Jennifer M. 2021. “‘We’re the Unicorns in STEM’”: Understanding How Academic and Social Experiences Influence Sense of Belonging for Latina Undergraduate Students.” Journal of Diversity in Higher Education 14 (3): 441–55. https://doi.org/10.1037/dhe0000176.

Schaller, Molly A. 2010. “Understanding the Impact of the Second Year of College.” In Helping Sophomores Succeed: Understanding and Improving the Second-year Experience (2nd ed.), edited by Mary Stewart Hunter, Barbara F. Tobolowsky, John N. Gardner, Scott E. Evenbeck, Jerry A. Pattengale, Molly A. Schaller, Laurie A. Schreiner, et al., 13–29. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Schoorman, F. David., Roger C. Mayer, and James H. Davis. 2007. “An Integrative Model of Organizational Trust: Past, Present, and Future.” Academy of Management Review 32 (2): 344–54. https://doi.org/10.2307/258792.

Schreiner, Laurie A. 2020. “From Surviving to Thriving During Transitions.” In Thriving in Transitions: A Research-based Approach to College Student Success (2nd ed.), edited by Laurie A. Schreiner, Michelle C. Louis, and Denise D. Nelson, 17–32. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina, National Resource Center for The First-Year Experience and Students in Transition.

Spencer, Liz, Jane Ritchie, Rachel Ormston, William O’Connor, and Matt Barnard, M. 2013. “Analysis: Principles and Processes.” In Qualitative Research Practice: A Guide for Social Science Students and Researchers (2nd ed.). Jane Ritchie, Jane Lewis, Carol McNaughton Nicholls, and Rachel Ormston, 269–94. London: Sage.

Thielmann, Isabel and Benjamin E. Hilbig 2015. “Trust: An Integrative Review From a Person-Situation Perspective.” Review of General Psychology 19 (3): 249–77.

Uslaner, Eric M. 2018. “The Study of Trust.” In The Oxford Handbook of Social and Political Trust, edited by Eric M. Uslaner, 3–13. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Vaccaro, Annemarie, and Barbara M. Newman. 2016. “Development of a Sense Of Belonging for Privileged and Minoritized Students: An Emergent Model.” Journal of College Student Development 75 (8): 924–42. https://doi.org/10.1353/csd.2016.0091.

Walsh, Andrew. 2015. “The Effect of Social Interaction on Mental Health Nurse Student Learning.” Nurse Education in Practice 15 (1): 7–12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nepr.2014.11.003.

Wang, Gaofeng, and Weiwei Hu. 2021. “Peer Relationships and College Students’ Cooperative Tendencies: Roles of Interpersonal Trust and Social Value Orientation.” Frontiers in Psychology 12. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.656412.

Williams, Brett, and Priya Reddy. 2016. “Does Peer-assisted Learning Improve Academic Performance? A Scoping Review.” Nurse Education Today 42: 23–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2016.03.024.

Wilson, Antoinette R., and Campbell Leaper. 2023. “Do Ethnic-Racial Identity Dimensions Moderate the Relations of Outgroup Discrimination and Ingroup Marginalization to Self-esteem in Black and Latinx Undergraduates?” Race and Social Problems 15: 444–59. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12552-022-09383-2.

Yomtov, Dani, Scott W. Plunkett, Rafi Efrat, and Adriana Garcia Marin. 2017. “Can Peer Mentors Improve First-Year Experiences of University Students?” Journal of College Student Retention: Research, Theory & Practice 19 (1): 25–44. https://doi.org/10.1177/1521025115611398.