We Teach as We See the World: Correspondence Between STEM Faculty Family Roles and Identities, System Narratives, and Self-Reported Teaching Practices

Kelsey S. Bitting; Caitlin Callahan; Laura Roselle

doi:10.20343/teachlearninqu.14.37

Authors

Kelsey S. Bitting Elon University https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3380-3822
Caitlin Callahan Grand Valley State University https://orcid.org/0009-0000-5745-4685
Laura Roselle Elon University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.20343/teachlearninqu.14.37

Keywords:

system narratives, family roles and identities, STEM teaching practice, integrated model of professional development, personal domain

Abstract

Despite extensive reform efforts, many STEM professors adhere to lecture-focused approaches, leading education researchers to question what shapes STEM teaching practices and how best to encourage the adoption of evidence-based alternatives. The interdisciplinary field of narrative research has shown that the stories we tell, and the system narratives that underlie them, offer insights into how we make sense of the world and correspond to a range of behaviors and outcomes. System narratives are stories about the nature and structure of the world. Furthermore, the roles we play in our families and our identities in that setting influence our behavior in a variety of other contexts. Our pilot study explores correlations between STEM faculty’s system narratives, roles and identities within their families, and self-reported teaching practices using inductive and deductive coding of interviews with 15 STEM faculty at two primarily undergraduate institutions. Through this work, we contribute to a growing strand of literature arguing that STEM faculty make decisions based on how they view themselves, their students, and the act of teaching, rather than defaulting to teaching as they were taught or adhering to disciplinary norms. By focusing on the personal domain of influences that shape our teaching and inviting faculty to shift the system narratives they draw from, we may find new avenues to engage colleagues in exploring active and student-centered teaching approaches that make sense to them.

Author Biographies

Kelsey S. Bitting, Elon University

Kelsey S. Bitting (United States) is an assistant professor of environmental studies at Elon University and a former associate director of teaching centers at Elon and Northeastern University. Her research examines evidence-based STEM teaching and student outcomes of engaged courses.
Caitlin Callahan, Grand Valley State University

Caitlin Callahan (United States) is an associate professor of geology at Grand Valley State University. Her scholarship explores questions related to broadening and supporting participation in STEM disciplines.
Laura Roselle, Elon University

Laura Roselle (United States) is Professor Emeritz at Elon University. Her work focuses on storytelling and strategic narratives in diverse applications including pedagogy, politics, and narrative psychology.

References

Adler, Jonathan M., William L. Dunlop, Robyn Fivush, Jennifer P. Lilgendahl, Jennifer Lodi-Smith, Dan P. McAdams, Kate C. McLean, Monisha Pasupathi, and Moin Syed. 2017. “Research Methods for Studying Narrative Identity: A Primer.” Social Psychological and Personality Science 8 (5): 519–27. https://doi.org/10.1177/1948550617698202.

Apkarian, Naneh, Charles Henderson, Marilyne Stains, Jeffrey Raker, Estrella Johnson, and Melissa Dancy. 2021. “What Really Impacts the Use of Active Learning in Undergraduate STEM Education? Results from a National Survey of Chemistry, Mathematics, and Physics Instructors.” PloS one 16 (2): e0247544. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0247544.

Biswas, Sreyasi, Rocio Benabentos, Eric Brewe, Geoff Potvin, Julian Edward, Marcy Kravec, and Laird Kramer. 2022. “Institutionalizing Evidence-based STEM Reform through Faculty Professional Development and Support Structures.” International Journal of STEM Education 9. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40594-022-00353-z.

Bitting, Kelsey, Leilani Arthurs, LeeAnna Chapman, Heather Macdonald, and Cathy Manduca. 2018. “Research on Institutional Change and Professional Development.” In Community Framework for Geoscience Education Research, edited by Kristen St. John. National Association of Geoscience Teachers. https://doi.org/10.25885/ger_framework/11.

Bouwma-Gearhart, Jana L., John D. Ivanovitch, Ellen M. Aster, and Andrew M. Bouwma. 2018. “Exploring Postsecondary Biology Educators’ Planning for Teaching to Advance Meaningful Education Improvement Initiatives.” CBE—Life Sciences Education 17 (3): ar37. https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.17-06-0101.

Brawner, Catherine E., Richard M. Felder, Rodney Allen, and Rebecca Brent. 2002. “A Survey of Faculty Teaching Practices and Involvement in Faculty Development Activities.” Journal of Engineering Education 91 (4): 393–96.

Brownell, Sara E., and Kimberly D. Tanner. 2012. “Barriers to Faculty Pedagogical Change: Lack of Training, Time, Incentives, and . . . Tensions with Professional Identity?” CBE—Life Sciences Education 11 (4): 333–46. https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.12-09-0163.

Clarke, David, and Hilary Hollingsworth. 2002. “Elaborating a Model of Teacher Professional Growth.” Teaching and Teacher Education 18 (8): 947–67.

Costabile, Kristi A., Randi Shedlosky-Shoemaker, and Adrienne B. Austin. 2020. “Universal Stories: How Narratives Satisfy Core Motives.” In Emerging Perspectives on Self and Identity, edited by Michael J. Bernstein and Elizabeth L. Haines. Routledge.

Dancy, Melissa, Charles Henderson, Naneh Apkarian, Estrella Johnson, Marilyne Stains, Jeffrey R. Raker, and Alexandra Lau. 2024. “Physics Instructors’ Knowledge and Use of Active Learning has Increased Over the Last Decade but Most Still Lecture Too Much.” Physical Review Physics Education Research 20 (1): 010119. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.20.010119.

Dancy, Melissa, Charles Henderson, and Chandra Turpen. 2016. “How Faculty Learn about and Implement Research-based Instructional Strategies: The Case of Peer Instruction.” Physical Review Physics Education Research 12 (1): 010110. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.12.010110.

Ebert-May, Diane, Terry L. Derting, Janet Hodder, Jennifer L. Momsen, Tammy M. Long, and Sarah E. Jardeleza. 2011. “What We Say is Not What We Do: Effective Evaluation of Faculty Professional Development Programs.” BioScience 61 (7): 550–58.

Emery, Nathan C., Jessica Middlemis Maher, and Diane Ebert-May. 2020. “Early-career Faculty Practice Learner-centered Teaching up to 9 Years After Postdoctoral Professional Development.” Science Advances 6 (25): eaba2091. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aba2091.

Emery, Nathan, Jessica Middlemis Maher, and Diane Ebert-May. 2021. “Environmental Influences and Individual Characteristics that Affect Learner-centered Teaching Practices.” PLoS One 16 (4): e0250760. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0250760.

Finelli, Cynthia J., Kevin Nguyen, Matthew DeMonbrun, Maura Borrego, Michael Prince, Jenefer Husman, Charles Henderson, Prateek Shekhar, and Cynthia K. Waters. 2018. “Reducing Student Resistance to Active Learning: Strategies for Instructors.” Journal of College Science Teaching 47 (5): 80–91. https://doi.org/10.2505/4/jcst18_047_05_80.

Fivush Robyn. 2019. Family Narratives and the Development of an Autobiographical Self: Social and Cultural Perspectives on Autobiographical Memory. Routledge.

Fivush, Robyn, Natalie Merril, and Kelly Marin. 2014. “Voice and Power: Constructing Moral Agency through Personal and Intergenerational Narratives.” In Talking about Right and Wrong: Parent-child Conversations as Contexts for Moral Development, edited by Cecelia Wainryb and Holly E. Reccia. Cambridge University Press.

Freeman, Scott, Sarah L. Eddy, Miles McDonough, Michelle K. Smith, Nnadozie Okoroafor, Hannah Jordt, and Mary Pat Wenderoth. 2014. “Active Learning Increases Student Performance in Science, Engineering, and Mathematics.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 111 (23): 8410–15. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1319030111.

Friberg, J. 11 July 2016. Might the 4M Framework Support SoTL Advocacy? The SoTL Advocate. https://illinoisstateuniversitysotl.wordpress.com/2016/07/11/might-the-4m-framework-support-sotl-advocacy/.

Gagalis-Hoffman, Kelly, Ramon B. Zabriskie, and Patti A. Freeman. 2016. “A Retrospective Consideration of Recreational Family Storytelling Among Parents and Their Adult Children.” Marriage & Family Review 52 (4): 392–412. https://doi.org/10.1080/01494929.2015.1100696.

Habermas, Tilmann, and Susan Bluck. 2000. “Getting a Life: The Emergence of the Life Story in Adolescence.” Psychological Bulletin 126 (5): 748–69.

Hashweh, Maher Z. 1996. “Effects of Science Teachers’ Epistemological Beliefs in Reaching.” Journal of Research in Science Teaching: The Official Journal of the National Association for Research in Science Teaching 33 (1): 47–63.

Henderson, Charles. 2012. “Use of Research-based Instructional Strategies in Introductory Physics: Where do Faculty Leave the Innovation-decision Process?.” Physical Review. Physics Education Research 8 (2): 020104. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevSTPER.8.020104.

Herbst, Patricio, and Daniel Chazan. 2011. “Research on Practical Rationality: Studying the Justification of Actions in Mathematics Teaching.” The Mathematics Enthusiast 8 (3): 405–62. https://doi.org/10.54870/1551-3440.1225.

Hora, Matthew T. 2014. “Exploring Faculty beliefs about Student Learning and their Role in Instructional Decision-making.” The Review of Higher Education 38 (1): 37–70. https://doi.org/10.1353/rhe.2014.0047.

Kane, Ruth, Susan Sandretto, and Chris Heath. 2002. “Telling Half the Story: A Critical Review of Research on the Teaching Beliefs and Practices of University Academics.” Review of Educational Research 72 (2): 177–228.

Kayumova, Shakhnoza, and Kathryn J. Strom. 2023. “Ontology, Epistemology, and Critical Theory in STEM Education.” In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Education, edited by George W. Noblit. Oxford University Press.

Luft, Julie A., and Gillian H. Roehrig. 2007. “Capturing Science Teachers’ Epistemological Beliefs: The Development of the Teacher Beliefs Interview.” The Electronic Journal for Research in Science & Mathematics Education 11 (2): 38–63.

Mataka, Lloyd M., Jon C. Saderholm, and Tracy T. Hodge. 2022. “College STEM Faculty Teaching Practices: The Influence of a Professional Development.” The Electronic Journal for Research in Science & Mathematics Education 26 (3): 40–56.

McAdams, Dan P. 1993. The Stories We Live By: Personal Myths and the Making of the Self. Guilford Press.

McAdams, Dan P. 2013. The Redemptive Self: Stories Americans Live By—Revised and Expanded Edition. Oxford University Press.

McAdams, Dan P., and Kate C. McLean. 2013. “Narrative Identity.” Current Directions in Psychological Science 22 (3): 233–38. https://doi.org/10.1177/09637214134756.

McLean, Kate C. 2016. The Co-authored Self: Family Stories and the Construction of Personal Identity. Oxford University Press.

Nisbett, Richard E., and Lee Ross. 1980. Human Inference: Strategies and Shortcomings of Social Judgment. Prentice Hall.

Pajares, M. Frank. 1992. “Teachers’ Beliefs and Educational Research: Cleaning Up a Messy Construct.” Review of Educational Research 62 (3): 307–32.

Ramamurthy, Chandra, Peixin Zuo, Gregory Armstrong, and Karl Andriessen. 2024. “The Impact of Storytelling on Building Resilience in Children: A Systematic Review.” Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 31 (4): 525–42. https://doi.org/10.1111/jpm.13008.

Read, Stephen John, and Lynn Carol Miller. 2014. “Stories are Fundamental to Meaning and Memory: For Social Creatures, Could it be Otherwise?.” In Knowledge and Memory: The Real Story: Advances in Social Cognition, Volume VIII, edited by Robert S. Wyer, Jr. Psychology Press.

Roselle, Laura, Alister Miskimmon, and Ben O’Loughlin. 2014. “Strategic Narrative: A New Means to Understand Soft Power.” Media, War & Conflict 7 (1): 70–84. https://doi.org/10.1177/175063521351669.

Rust, Chris. 1998. “The Impact of Educational Development Workshops on Teachers’ Practice.” The International Journal for Academic Development 3 (1): 72–80.

Saitta, Erin, and Julie Donnelly. 2023. “The Role and Influence of the Discipline-based Education Research (DBER) Community on STEM Faculty Development.” In Handbook of STEM Faculty Development, edited by S. M. Linder, C. M. Lee, S. K. Stefl, and K. A. High. Information Age Publishing.

Scherer, Hannah H., Megan O’Rourke, Rachel Seman-Varner, and Peter Ziegler. 2020. “Coteaching in Higher Education: A Case Study of Instructor Learning.” Journal of Effective Teaching in Higher Education 3 (1): 15–29.

Sheafer, Tamir, Shaul R. Shenhav, and Kenneth Goldstein. 2011. “Voting for Our Story: A Narrative Model of Electoral Choice in Multiparty Systems.” Comparative Political Studies 44 (3): 313–38. https://doi.org/10.1177/0010414010384372.

Shultz, Mollee, Jayson Nissen, Eleanor Close, and Ben Van Dusen. 2022. “The Role of Epistemological Beliefs in STEM Faculty’s Decisions to Use Culturally Relevant Pedagogy at Hispanic-Serving Institutions.” International Journal of STEM Education 9: 9. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40594-022-00349-9.

Stains, Marilyne, Jordan Harshman, Megan K. Barker, Stephanie V. Chasteen, Renee Cole, Sue Ellen DeChenne-Peters, M. Kevin Eagan Jr., J. M. Esson, J. K. Knight, F. A. Laski, M. Levis-Fitzgerald, C. J. Lee et al. 2018. “Anatomy of STEM teaching in North American universities.” Science 359 (6383): 1468–70. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aap8892.

Stone, Elizabeth. 2017. Black Sheep and Kissing Cousins: How Our Family Stories Shape Us. Routledge.

Theobald, Elli J., Mariah J. Hill, Elisa Tran, Sweta Agrawal, E. Nicole Arroyo, Shawn Behling, Nyasha Chambwe, Dianne Laboy Cintron, Jacob D. Cooper, Gideon Dunster, Jared A. Grummer, Kelly Hennessey, et al. 2020. “Active Learning Narrows Achievement Gaps for Underrepresented Students in Undergraduate Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117 (12): 6476–83. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1916903117.

Turpen, Chandra, and Noah D. Finkelstein. 2009. “Not All Interactive Engagement is the Same: Variations in Physics Professors’ Implementation of Peer Instruction.” Physical Review Special Topics-Physics Education Research 5 (2): 020101.

Wilton, Mike, Jeffrey Maloy, Laura Beaster-Jones, Brian K. Sato, Stanley M. Lo, and Daniel Z. Grunspan. 2024. “Instructional Influencers: Teaching Professors as Potential Departmental Change Agents in Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion.” CBE—Life Sciences Education 23 (3): ar35. https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.24-03-0102.

Yerrick, Randy, Helen Parke, and Jeff Nugent. 1997. “Struggling to Promote Deeply Rooted Change: The ‘Filtering Effect’ of Teachers’ Beliefs on Understanding Transformational Views of Teaching Science.” Science Education 81 (2): 137–59.