Participation in Higher Education Classroom Discussions: How Students’ Identities Influence Perspective Taking and Engagement

Crystena  Parker-Shandal

doi:10.20343/teachlearninqu.11.19

Authors

Crystena Parker-Shandal University of Waterloo https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8882-5773

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.20343/teachlearninqu.11.19

Keywords:

postsecondary education, classroom discussions, identity, controversial issues, first-generation students

Abstract

This study examines the impact of students’ identities on how students participate in classroom discussions in postsecondary courses. Participation in such discussions is known to increase students’ learning, but, despite this, little is known about how students’ identities influence how and whether they choose to participate. Drawn from a larger study on the experiences of postsecondary instructors and students, this article focuses on students’ perspectives and experiences. Survey data were collected from undergraduate students enrolled in an interdisciplinary undergraduate program. Students’ race, religion, gender, and their first- or continuing-generation university status were found to have varying influences on their participation in classroom discussions. Most students with marginalized identities opted out of actively participating in discussions about contentious or sociopolitical topics. This study suggests that inclusive approaches to classroom discussion can be useful in promoting students’ engagement and academic learning.

Click here to read the corresponding ISSOTL blog post.

Author Biography

Crystena Parker-Shandal, University of Waterloo

Crystena Parker-Shandal is an associate professor in social development studies at Renison University College at the University of Waterloo, Canada. She holds a PhD in Curriculum Studies and Teacher Development and a Master’s of Teaching from the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education at the University of Toronto. She is an Ontario Certified Teacher. www.drparkershandal.com

References

Akman, Özkan, and Bülent Alagöz. 2018. “Relation Between Metacognitive Awareness and Participation to Class Discussion of University Students.” Universal Journal of Educational Research 6 (1): 11–24.

Alderman, Derek, Rodrigo Narro Perez, LaToya E. Eaves, Phil Klein, and Solange Muñoz. 2021. “Reflections on Operationalizing an Anti-racism Pedagogy: Teaching as Regional Storytelling.” Journal of Geography in Higher Education 45 (2): 186–200.

An Le, Dao Thanh Binh, and John Hockey. 2022. “Critical Thinking in the Higher Education Classroom: Knowledge, Power, Control and Identities.” British Journal of Sociology of Education 43 (1): 140–58.

Applebaum, Barbara. 2017. “Comforting Discomfort as Complicity: White Fragility and the Pursuit of Invulnerability.” Hypatia 32, no. 4 (Fall): 862–75.

Bakhtin, Mikhail M. 2010. Speech Genres and Other Late Essays. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.

Bauer, Kelly, and Kelly Clancy. 2018. “Teaching Race and Social Justice at a Predominantly White Institution.” Journal of Political Science Education 14 (1): 72–85.

Bellet, Benjamin W., Payton J. Jones, Cynthia A. Meyersburg, Miranda M. Brenneman, Kaitlin E. Morehead, and Richard J. McNally. 2020. “Trigger Warnings and Resilience in College Students: A Preregistered Replication and Extension.” Journal of Experimental Psychology 26 (4): 717–23. https://doi.org/10.1037/xap0000270.

Bereiter, Carl, and Marlene Scardamalia. 2018. “Intentional Learning as a Goal of Instruction.” In Knowing, Learning, and Instruction, 361–92. New York: Routledge.

Bickmore, Kathy, and Christina Parker. 2014. “Constructive Conflict Talk in Classrooms: Divergent Approaches to Addressing Divergent Perspectives.” Theory & Research in Social Education 42 (3): 291–335.

Bodenner, Chris. 2017. “The Surprising Revolt at the Most Liberal College in the Country.” The Atlantic, November 2, 2017. https://www.theatlantic.com/education/arshive/2017/11/the-surprising-revolt-at-reed/544682/.

Boyd, Maureen P., and William C. Markarian. 2011. “Dialogic Teaching: Talk in Service of a Dialogic Stance.” Language and Education 25 (6): 515–34.

Carnell, Eileen. 2007. “Conceptions of Effective Teaching in Higher Education: Extending the Boundaries.” Teaching in Higher Education 12 (1): 25–40.

Clancy, Kelly A., and Kelly Bauer. 2018. “Creating Student-Scholar-Activists: Discourse Instruction and Social Justice in Political Science Classrooms.” New Political Science 40 (3): 542–57.

Combs, Aidan, Graham Tierney, Fatima Alqabandi, Devin Cornell, Gabriel Varela, Andrés Castro Araújo, Lisa Argyle, Christopher A. Bail, and Alexander Volfovsky. 2022. “Perceived Gender and Political Persuasion: A Social Media Field Experiment during the 2020 Democratic National Primary.” SocArXiv Papers. https://doi.org/10.31235/osf.io/537qn.

Creswell, John W., and J. David Creswell. 2017. Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publishing.

Cuellar, Marcela G. 2022. “Introduction: Transforming Higher Education—Reflections on the Past and Possibilities for the Future.” In Emancipatory Change in US Higher Education. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International.

Cuellar, Marcela G., Alicia Bencomo Garcia, and Kem Saichaie. 2022. “Reaffirming the Public Purposes of Higher Education: First-Generation and Continuing Generation Students’ Perspectives.” The Journal of Higher Education 93 (2): 273–96. https://doi.org/10.1080/00221546.2021.1979849.

Daddow, Angela. 2016. “Curricula and Pedagogic Potentials when Educating Diverse Students in Higher Education: Students’ Funds of Knowledge as a Bridge to Disciplinary Learning.” Teaching in Higher Education 21(17): 741–58.

Davies, Lynn. 2004. “Education for Positive Conflict and Interruptive Democracy.” In Education and Conflict: Complexity and Chaos, edited by Lynn Davies, 203–24. London: Routledge Falmer.

Davis, Hope Smith. 2012. “Discussion as a Bridge: Strategies that Engage Adolescent and Adult Learning Styles in the Postsecondary Classroom.” Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning 13 (1): 68–76.

Diem, Sarah, and Anjalé D. Welton. 2020. Anti-Racist Educational Leadership and Policy: Addressing Racism in Public Education. New York: Routledge.

Dods, Jennifer. 2015. “Bringing Trauma to School: Sharing the Educational Experience of Three Youths.” Exceptionality Education International 25 (1): 112–35. https://doi.org/10.5206/eei.v25i1.7719.

Doody, Owen, and Mairead Condon. 2012. “Increasing Student Involvement and Learning through Using Debate as an Assessment.” Nurse Education in Practice 12 (4): 232–37.

Dudley-Marling, Curt. 2013. “Discussion in Postsecondary Classrooms: A Review of the Literature.” SAGE Open 3 (4): 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1177/2158244013515688.

Ellsworth, Elizabeth. 1989. “Why Doesn’t This Feel Empowering? Working through the Repressive Myths of Critical Pedagogy.” Harvard Educational Review 59 (3): 297–325.

Folger, Joseph P., Marshall S. Poole, and Randall K. Stutman. 2021. Working through Conflict: Strategies for Relationships, Groups, and Organizations, 9th edition. New York: Routledge.

Fox, Helen. 2009. When Race Breaks Out: Conversations about Race and Racism in College Classrooms, volume 6. New York: Peter Lang.

Freire, Paulo. (1970) 1994. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. New York: Continuum.

Garside, Colleen. 1996. “Look Who’s Talking: A Comparison of Lecture and Group Discussion Teaching Strategies in Developing Critical Thinking Skills.” Communication Education 45 (3): 212–27. https://doi.org/10.1080/03634529609379050.

Godfrey, Erin B., and Justina K. Grayman. 2014. “Teaching Citizens: The Role of Open Classroom Climate in Fostering Critical Consciousness among Youth.” Journal of Youth and Adolescence 43 (11): 1801–17.

Gunnlaugson, Olen, and Janet Moore. 2009. “Dialogue Education in the Post-Secondary Classroom: Reflecting on Dialogue Processes from Two Higher Education Settings in North America.” Journal of Further and Higher Education 33 (2): 171–81.

Hall, Kayon A. 2022. “Undocumented Black Students and Hermeneutical Injustice: Higher Education’s Role in Leaving Them out of the Undocumented Conversation.” Journal of First-Generation Student Success 2 (3): 143–60.

Hanna, Debra R. 2014. “Using Guided Debates to Teach Current Issues.” Journal of Nursing Education 53 (6): 352–55.

Harbin, M. Brielle, Aimie Thurber, and Joe Bandy. 2019. “Teaching Race, Racism, and Racial Justice: Pedagogical Principles and Classroom Strategies for Course Instructors.” Race and Pedagogy Journal: Teaching and Learning for Justice 4 (1): 1–37. https://soundideas.pugetsound.edu/rpj/vol4/iss1/1.

Harrison, Neil, Jacqueline Burke, and Ivan Clarke. 2020. “Risky Teaching: Developing a Trauma-Informed Pedagogy for Higher Education.” Teaching in Higher Education 28 (1): 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1080/13562517.2020.1786046.

Howard, Jay R. 2015. Discussion in the College Classroom: Getting Your Students Engaged and Participating in Person and Online. New York: Wiley.

Howard, Jay R., and Amanda L. Henney. 1998. “Student Participation and Instructor Gender in the Mixed-Age College Classroom.” The Journal of Higher Education 69 (4): 384–405.

Howard, Patrick, Charity Becker, Sean Wiebe, Mindy Carter, Peter Gouzouasis, Mitchell McLarnon, Pamela Richardson, Kathryn Ricketts, and Layal Schuman. 2018. “Creativity and Pedagogical Innovation: Exploring Teachers’ Experiences of Risk-Taking.” Journal of Curriculum Studies 50 (6): 850–64.

Islam, Md. Kabirul, Md. Fouad H. Sarker, and M. Saiful Islam. 2022. “Promoting Student-Centred Blended Learning in Higher Education: A Model.” E-Learning and Digital Media 19 (1): 36–54.

Kahne, Joseph, and Benjamin Bowyer. 2017. “Educating for Democracy in a Partisan Age: Confronting the Challenges of Motivated Reasoning and Misinformation.” American Educational Research Journal 54 (1): 3–34. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831216679817.

Kazanjian, Christopher J., and David Rutledge. 2022. “The Quiet Revolution: Humanizing Institutions of Higher Education in the Wake of Existential Trauma.” In Emancipatory Change in US Higher Education, edited by Kenneth R. Roth, Felix Kumah-Abiwu, and Zachary S. Ritter, 151–72. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International.

Kester, Kevin, Mary Abura, Chaewon Sohn, and Ella Rho. 2022. “Higher Education Peacebuilding in Conflict-Affected Societies: Beyond the Good/Bad Binary.” International Journal of Comparative Education and Development 24 (3/4): 160–76.

Kishimoto, Kyoko. 2018. “Anti-Racist Pedagogy: From Faculty’s Self-Reflection to Organizing within and beyond the Classroom.” Race Ethnicity and Education 21 (4): 540–54.

Kostovicova, Denisa, and Tom Paskhalis. 2021. “Gender, Justice and Deliberation: Why Women Don’t Influence Peacemaking.” International Studies Quarterly 65 (2): 263–76.

Kuhn, Deanna. 2010. “Teaching and Learning Science as Argument.” Science Education 94 (5): 810–24.

Moats, Michael. 2019. “White Privilege: A Multifaceted Responsibility.” In Humanistic Approaches to Multiculturalism and Diversity: Perspectives on Existence and Difference, edited by Louis Hoffman, Heatherlyn Cleare-Hoffman, Nathaniel Granger, Jr., and David St. John, 90–102. New York: Routledge.

Moustakim, Mohamed. 2007. “From Transmission to Dialogue: Promoting Critical Engagement in Higher Education Teaching and Learning.” Educational Action Research 15 (2): 209–20.

Nieminen, Juuso H. 2022. “Assessment for Inclusion: Rethinking Inclusive Assessment in Higher Education.” Teaching in Higher Education: 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/13562517.2021.2021395.

Nunn, Claudia E. 1996. “Discussion in the College Classroom: Triangulating Observational and Survey Results.” The Journal of Higher Education 67 (3): 243–66.

Ogunyemi, Dotun, Camille Clare, Yaritzy M. Astudillo, Melissa Marseille, Eugene Manu, and Sun Kim. 2020. “Microaggressions in the Learning Environment: A Systematic Review.” Journal of Diversity in Higher Education 13 (2): 97–119. https://doi.org/10.1037/dhe0000107.

Pace, Judith L. 2019. “Contained Risk-Taking: Preparing Preservice Teachers to Teach Controversial Issues in Three Countries.” Theory & Research in Social Education 47 (2): 228–60.

Pace, Judith L. 2022. “Learning to Teach Controversial Issues in a Divided Society: Adaptive Appropriation of Pedagogical Tools.” Democracy and Education 30 (1): 1–11.

Parker, Christina. 2016a. Peacebuilding, Citizenship, and Identity: Empowering Conflict and Dialogue in Multicultural Classrooms. Rotterdam/Boston/Taipei: Brill | Sense.

Parker, Christina. 2016b. “Pedagogical Tools for Peacebuilding Education: Engaging and Empathizing with Diverse Perspectives in Multicultural Elementary Classrooms.” Theory & Research in Social Education 44 (1): 104–40.

Parker, Christina, and Kathy Bickmore. 2012. “Conflict Management and Dialogue with Diverse Immigrant Students: Novice Teachers’ Approaches and Concerns.” Journal of Teaching and Learning 8 (2): 47–64.

Parker-Shandal, Crystena. 2022. Restorative Justice in the Classroom: Liberating students’ Voices through Relational Pedagogy. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

Parker-Shandal, Crystena. 2023. “White Liberalism, Racism, and Restorative Justice in Schools.” In The Other Elephant in the (Class)Room: White Liberalism and the Persistence of Racism in Education, edited by Cheryl E. Matias and Paul C. Gorski. New York: Teachers College Press.

Parker-Shandal, Crystena, Hicham Tiflati, and W. Y. Alice Chan. 2023. “Going Beyond Campus to Strengthen the Campus: Confronting Hate, Extremism, and Anti-Semitism through Restorative Justice and Peacebuilding Education.” In Confronting Anti-Semitism on Campus. New York: Peter Lang.

Ramos, Alcida R. 2012. “The Politics of Perspectivism.” Annual Review of Anthropology 41: 481–94.

Reda, Mary M. 2009. Between Speaking and Silence: A Study of Quiet Students. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.

Rocca, Kelly A. 2010. “Student Participation in the College Classroom: An Extended Multidisciplinary Literature Review.” Communication Education 59 (2): 185–213.

Seals, Dmitri. 2018. “Toward a Resolution for Teacher-Student Conflict: Crafting Spaces of Rigorous Freedom with Classroom Debate.” In Constructivist Education in an Age of Accountability, 211–30. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.

Sedova, Klara, Martin Sedlacek, and Roman Svaricek. 2016. “Teacher Professional Development as a Means of Transforming Student Classroom Talk.” Teaching and Teacher Education 57 no. 1 (July): 14–25.

Spencer, Leland G. 2015. “Engaging Undergraduates in Feminist Classrooms: An Exploration of Professors’ Practices.” Equity & Excellence in Education 48 (2): 195–211.

Spry, Amber D. 2022. “The #RiceBreaker: Facilitating Intercultural Dialogues in the Classroom by Engaging Shared Experiences.” Journal of Political Science Education. https://doi.org/10.1080/15512169.2022.2116711.

Strom, Kathryn J., and Adrian D. Martin. 2022. “Toward a Critical Posthuman Understanding of Teacher Development and Practice: A Multi-case Study of Beginning Teachers.” Teaching and Teacher Education 114 no. 5 (June): 103688. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2022.103688.

Tang, Cara, and Christian Servin. 2020. “Challenges and Opportunities During COVID: A Community College Perspective.” ACM Inroads 11 (4): 12–16. https://doi.org/10.1145/3429984.

Tannen, Deborah. 2002. “Agonism in Academic Discourse.” Journal of Pragmatics 34, no. 10–11 (October–November): 1651–69.

Tatum, Holly E., Beth M. Schwartz, Peggy A. Schimmoeller, and Nicole E. Perry. 2013. “Classroom Participation and Student-Faculty Interactions: Does Gender Matter?” The Journal of Higher Education 84 (6): 745–68.

Teitelbaum, Kenneth. 2022. “Curriculum, Conflict, and Critical Race Theory.” Phi Delta Kappan 103 (5): 47–53.

Torney-Purta, Judith, Rainer Lehmann, Hans Oswald, and Wolfram Schultz. 2001. Citizenship and Education in 28 Countries: Civic Knowledge and Engagement at Age 14. Amsterdam: International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement.

Tyson, Karolyn. 2003. “Notes from the Back of the Room: Problems and Paradoxes in the Schooling of Young Black Students.” Sociology of Education 76, no. 4 (October): 326–43. https://doi.org/10.2307/1519869.

Van Dyke, Nella, and Griff Tester. 2014. “Dangerous Climates: Factors Associated with Variation in Racist Hate Crimes on College Campuses.” Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 30 (3): 290–309.

Visser, Penny S., Jon A. Krosnick, Jesse Marquette, and Michael Curtin. 1996. “Mail Surveys for Election Forecasting? An Evaluation of The Columbus Dispatch Poll.” Public Opinion Quarterly 60, no. 2 (Summer): 181–227.

Wansink, Bjorn G.-J., Hanneke Mol, Jaël Kortekaas, and Tim Mainhard. 2023. “Discussing Controversial Issues in the Classroom: Exploring Students’ Safety Perceptions and Their Willingness to Participate.” Teaching and Teacher Education 125 (April): 104044. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2023.104044.

Wood, Margaret, and Feng Su. 2017. “What Makes an Excellent Lecturer? Academics’ Perspectives on the Discourse of ‘Teaching Excellence’ in Higher Education.” Teaching in Higher Education 22 (4): 451–66.