Authenticity and Psychological Safety: Building and Encouraging Talent Among Underrepresented Students in STEM
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.20343/teachlearninqu.10.31Keywords:
first-generation students, mentoring, psychological safety, STEM, underrepresented studentsAbstract
The Undergraduate Scholarships with Mathematics and Science Training, Exploration, and Research Program (US MASTER) is a STEM scholarship program funded by the United States National Science Foundation. It was implemented at an upper-Midwest institution to target and provide structured support to low-income, academically talented undergraduates in biology, chemistry, geography and geographic information science (GISc), environmental sciences, and physics and astrophysics. In addition to providing financial support, the program features an integrated approach to mentorship and advising consisting of an ongoing seminar course in which students engage in collaborative projects, research experiences with a faculty mentor, and targeted academic advising. As part of our assessment efforts, we interviewed student participants regarding their experiences. A consistent theme emerged regarding mentorship: in addition to providing access to professional socialization experiences and the facilitation of competency and performance, students reported that it was the ability to form close relationships based on personal authenticity and feelings of psychological safety and trust that provided the best scaffolding for success in a challenging STEM environment.
Metrics
References
Aikens, Melissa L., Melissa M. Robertson, Sona Sadselia, Keiana Watkins, Mara Evans, Christopher R. Runyon, Lillian T. Eby, and Erin L. Dolan. 2017. “Race and Gender Differences in Undergraduate Research Mentoring Structures and Research Outcomes.” CBE – Life Sciences Education 16 (2): 1–12. https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.16-07-0211.
Allan, Elizabeth J. 2011. Women’s Status in Higher Education: Equity Matters (ASHE Higher Education Report, Vol. 37, No. 1). Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons.
American Association of University Women (AAUW). 2010. Why So Few? Women in Science, Engineering, and Mathematics. Washington, DC: AAUW.
Arora, Ridhi and Santosh Rangnekar. 2015. “Relationships between Emotional Stability, Psychosocial Mentoring Support and Career Resilience.” Europe’s Journal of Psychology 11 (1): 16–33.
Asche, Kelly. 2018. “State of Rural MN, 2018.” Mankato: Center for Rural Policy and Development. Retrieved from https://www.ruralmn.org/state-of-rural-minnesota-2018/.
Avraamidou, Lucy. 2020. “Science Identity as a Landscape of Becoming: Rethinking Recognition and Emotions through an Intersectionality Lens.” Cultural Studies of Science Education 15 (3): 323–45.
Braun, Virginia, and Victoria Clark. 2006. “Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology.” Qualitative Research in Psychology 3 (2): 77–101. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa.
Carlone, Heidi B., and Angela Johnson. 2007. “Understanding the Science Experiences of Successful Women of Color: Science Identity as an Analytic Lens.” Journal of Research in Science Teaching 44 (8): 1187–218. https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.20237.
Carmeli, Abraham. 2007. “Social Capital, Psychological Safety and Learning Behaviours from Failure in Organisations.” Long Range Planning 40 (1): 30–44. https://www.jstor.org/stable/41683863.
Chang, Mitchell J., M. Kevin Eagan, Monica H. Lin, and Sylvia Hurtado. 2011. “Considering the Impact of Racial Stigmas and Science Identity: Persistence Among Biomedical and Behavioral Science Aspirants.” Journal of Higher Education 82 (5): 564–96. https://doi.org/10.1080/00221546.2011.11777218.
Chemers, Martin M., Eileen L. Zurbriggen, Moin Syed, Barbara K. Goza, and Steve Bearman. 2011. “The Role of Efficacy and Identity in Science Career Commitment Among Underrepresented Minority Students.” Journal of Social Issues 67 (3): 469–91. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-4560.2011.01710.x.
Chubin, Daryl E., and Anthony L. DePass. 2017. “Undergraduate STEM Education.” STEM and Medicine 5 (1): 13–26. https://www.understandinginterventionsjournal.org/article/1947-undergraduate-stem-education.
Conefrey, Theresa. 2018. “Supporting First-Generation Students’ Adjustment to College with High-Impact Practices.” Journal of College Student Retention: Research, Theory & Practice 23 (1): 139-60. https://doi.org/10.1177%2F1521025118807402.
Cooper, Catherine R. 2011. Bridging Multiple Worlds: Cultures, Identities, and Pathways to College. New York: Oxford University Press.
Crisp, Gloria, and Irene Cruz. 2009. “Mentoring College Students: A Critical Review of the Literature Between 1990 and 2007.” Research in Higher Education 50: 52–45.
Dahlberg, Maria Lund, and Angela Byars-Winston. 2019. The Science of Effective Mentorship in STEMM. Washington, DC: National Academies Press. National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine; Policy and Global Affairs; Board on Higher Education and Workforce; Committee on Effective Mentoring in STEMM. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK552775/.
Daniels, Heather A., Sara E. Grineski, Timothy W. Collins, and Angela H. Frederick. 2019. “Navigating Social Relationships with Mentors and Peers: Comfort and Belonging Among Men and Women in STEM Summer Research Programs.” CBE – Life Sciences Education 18 (2): 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.18-08-0150.
Dawson, Amy E., Bianca L. Bernstein, and Jennifer M. Bekki. 2015. “Providing the Psychosocial Benefits of Mentoring to Women in STEM: CareerWISE as an Online Solution.” New Directions for Higher Education 171 (special issue): 53–62. https://doi.org/10.1002/he.20142.
Edmondson, Amy. 1999. “Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams.” Administrative Science Quarterly 44 (2): 350–83. https://doi.org/10.2307/2666999.
Espinosa, Lorelle. 2011. “Pipelines and Pathways: Women of Color in Undergraduate STEM Majors and the College Experiences that Contribute to Persistence.” Harvard Educational Review 81 (2): 209–41. https://doi.org/10.17763/haer.81.2.92315ww157656k3u.
Estrada, Mica, Paul R. Hernandez, and P. Wesley Schultz. 2018. “A Longitudinal Study of How Quality Mentorship and Research Experience Integrate Underrepresented Minorities into STEM Careers.” CBE – Life Sciences Education 17 (1): 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.17-04-0066.
Fifolt, Matthew, Jeffrey Engler, and Gypsy Abbott. 2014. “Bridging STEM Professions for McNair Scholars through Faculty Mentoring and Preparation.” College and University 89 (3): 24–33. https://aacrao-web.s3.amazonaws.com/files/ERRrFKrUSgKa26VLIPL2_CUJ8903_WEB.pdf.
Fletcher, Joyce K., and Belle R. Ragins. 2007. “Stone Center Relational Cultural Theory: A Window on Relational Mentoring.” In The Handbook of Mentoring at Work: Theory, Research and Practice, edited by Belle Rose Ragins and Kathy E. Kram. 373–99. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.
Fries-Britt, Sharon, and Jeanette Snider. 2015. “Mentoring Outside the Line: The Importance of Authenticity, Transparency, and Vulnerability in Effective Mentoring Relationships.” New Directions for Higher Education 171 (Special Issue, Mentoring as Transformative Practice: Supporting Student and Faculty Diversity): 3–11. https://doi.org/10.1002/he.20137.
Fries-Britt, Sharon, and Bridget Turner Kelly. 2005. “Retaining Each Other: Narratives of Two African American Women in the Academy.” Urban Review 37 (3): 221–42.
Goerisch, Denise, Jae Basiliere, Ashley Rosener, Kimberly McKee, Jodee Hunt, and Tonya M. Parker. 2019. “Mentoring With: Reimagining Mentoring Across the University.” Gender, Place & Culture 26 (12): 1740–58.
James, Julie M., Ashley Rayner, and Jeanette Bruno. 2015. “Are You My Mentor? New Perspectives and Research on Informal Mentorship.” The Journal of Academic Librarianship 41: 532–39.
Kark, Ronit, and Abraham Carmeli. 2009. “Alive and Creating: The Mediating Role of Vitality and Aliveness in the Relationship between Psychological Safety and Creative Work Involvement.” Journal of Organizational Behavior 30 (6): 785–804.
Kendricks, Kimberly D., Krishnakumar V. Nedunuri, and Anthony R. Arment. 2013. “Minority Student Perceptions of the Impact of Mentoring to Enhance Academic Performance in STEM Disciplines.” Journal of STEM Education: Innovations and Research 14 (2): 38–46.
Kuh, George D. 2008. High-Impact Educational Practices: What They Are, Who Has Access to Them, and Why They Matter. Washington, DC: Association of American Colleges and Universities.
Le, Paul T., Leanne Doughty, Amreen Nasim Thompson, and Laurel M. Hartley. 2019. “Investigating Undergraduate Biology Students’ Science Identity Production.” CBE – Life Sciences Education 18 (50): 1–16.
Leudke, Courtney L. 2017. “Person First, Student Second: Staff and Administrators of Color Supporting Students of Color Authentically in Higher Education.” Journal of College Student Development 58 (1): 37–52.
Liang, Belle, G. Anne Bogat, and Nicole Duffy. 2014. “Gender in Mentoring Relationships.” In Handbook of Youth Mentoring, edited by David L. DuBois and Michael J. Karcher, 159–74. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Liang, Belle, Allison J. Tracy, Catherine A. Taylor, and Linda M. Williams. 2002. “Mentoring College-Age Women: A Relational Approach.” American Journal of Community Psychology 30 (2): 271–88.
Lunsford, Laura G., Vicki Baker, Kimberly A. Griffin, and W. Brad Johnson. 2013. “Mentoring: A Typology of Costs for Higher Education Faculty.” Mentoring & Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 21 (2): 126–49.
McDaniel, Anne, and Matthew Van Jura. 2020. “High-Impact Practices: Evaluating their Effect on College Completion.” Journal of College Student Retention: Research, Theory & Practice.
McKinsey, Elizabeth. 2016. “Faculty Mentoring Undergraduates: The Nature, Development, and Benefits of Mentoring Relationships.” Teaching & Learning Inquiry 4 (1): 25–39.
Nakkula, Michael J., and John T. Harris. 2013. “Assessing Mentoring Relationships.” In Handbook of Youth Mentoring, edited by David L. DuBois and Michael J. Karcher, 100–17. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
National Academy of Sciences, National Academy of Engineering, & Institute of Medicine. 2011. Expanding Underrepresented Minority Participation. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
Núñez, Anne‐Marie, Elizabeth Murakami Ramalho, and Kimberly K. Cuero. 2010. “Pedagogy for Equity: Teaching in a Hispanic‐Serving Institution.” Innovative Higher Education 35 (3): 177–90.
Núñez, Anne-Marie, Elizabeth T. Murakami, and Leslie D. Gonzales. 2015. “Weaving Authenticity and Legitimacy: Latina Faculty Peer Mentoring.” New Directions for Higher Education 171 (Special Issue—Mentoring as Transformative Practice: Supporting Student and Faculty Diversity): 87–96.
Ong, Maria, Carole Wright, Lorelle L. Espinosa, and Gary Orfield. 2011. “Inside the Double Bind: A Synthesis of Empirical Research on Undergraduate and Graduate Women of Color in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics.” Harvard Educational Review 81: 172–208.
Phinney, Jean S., Cidhinnia M. Torres Campos, Delia M. Padilla Kallemeyn, and Chami Kim. 2011. “Processes and Outcomes of a Mentoring Program for Latino College Freshmen.” Journal of Social Issues 67: 599–621.
President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST). 2012. Engage to Excel: Producing One Million Additional College Graduates with Degrees in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics. Washington, DC: Executive Office of the President. Retrieved from https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED541511.pdf.
Robnett, Rachael D., Paul A. Nelson, Eileen L. Zurbriggen, Faye J. Crosby, and Martin M. Chemers. 2019. “The Form and Function of STEM Research Mentoring: A Mixed-Methods Analysis Focusing on Ethnically Diverse Undergraduates and their Mentors.” Emerging Adulthood 7 (3): 180–93.
Rosser, Sue V., and Mark Zachary Taylor. 2009. “Why Are We Still Worried about Women in Science?” Academe 95 (3): 7–10.
Sadler, Troy D., Stephen Burgin, Lyle McKinney, and Luis Ponjuan. 2010. “Learning Science Through Research Apprenticeships: A Critical Review of the Literature.” Journal of Research in Science Teaching 47: 235–56.
Saffie-Robertson, Ma. Carolina. 2020. “It’s Not You, It’s Me: An Exploration of Mentoring Experiences for Women in STEM.” Sex Roles 83: 566–79.
Saha, Mili. 2019. “Contextual Mentoring: Theory and Practice Alignment.” Canadian Journal for New Scholars in Education 10 (2): 33–52.
Schreiner, Laurie A., Patrice Noel, Edward Anderson, and Linda Cantwell. 2011. “The Impact of Faculty and Staff on High-Risk College Student Persistence.” Journal of College Student Development 52: 321–38.
Skvoretz, John, Gladis Kersaint, Rebecca Campbell-Montalvo, Jonathan D. Ware, Chrystal A. S. Smith, Ellen Puccia, Julie P. Martin, Reginald Lee, George MacDonald, and Hesborn Wao. 2020. “Pursuing an Engineering Major: Social Capital of Women and Underrepresented Minorities.” Studies in Higher Education 45 (3), 592–607.
Smit, Renee’. 2012. “Towards a Clearer Understanding of Student Disadvantage in Higher Education: Problematising Deficit Thinking.” Higher Education Research & Development 31 (3), 369–80.
Spronken-Smith, Rachel, Nell Buissink-Smith, Carol Bond, and Gabrielle Grigg. 2015. “Graduates’ Orientations to Higher Education and their Retrospective Experiences of Teaching and Learning.” Teaching & Learning Inquiry 3 (2): 55–70.
Tenenbaum, Harriet R., Faye J. Crosby, and Melissa D. Gliner. 2001. “Mentoring Relationships in Graduate School.” Journal of Vocational Behavior 59: 326–41.
Thomas, David A. 2001. “The Truth About Mentoring Minorities: Race Matters.” Harvard Business Review 74 (5): 98.
Tsuei, Sian Hsiang-Te, Dongho Lee, Charles Ho, Glenn Regehr, and Laura Nimmon. 2019. “Exploring the Construct of Psychological Safety in Medical Education.” Academic Medicine 94 (11): S28–S35.
Värlander, Sara. 2008. “The Role of Students’ Emotions in Formal Feedback Situations.” Teaching in Higher Education 13 (2): 145–56.
Webb, Nathan G., and Laura Obrycki Barrett. 2014. “Instructor-Student Rapport in Taiwan ESL Classrooms.” Teaching & Learning Inquiry 2 (2): 9–23.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Daphne E. Pedersen, Alena Kubátová, Rebecca B. Simmons
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
