Telling Students it’s O.K. to Fail, but Showing Them it Isn’t: Dissonant Paradigms of Failure in Higher Education
Keywords:generative failure, stigmatized failure, meritocracy, precarity, wise interventions
Educators increasingly extol failure as a necessary component of learning and growth. However, students frequently experience failure as a source of fear and anxiety that impedes risk-taking and experimentation. This essay examines the dissonance between these generative and stigmatized paradigms of failure, and it offers ideas for better negotiating this dissonance. After conceptualizing the two paradigms, I examine various factors that reinforce failure’s stigmatization. I emphasize precarious meritocracy, a neoliberal ethos driven by hypercompetitive individualism that makes success a zero-sum game, and that causes especially significant harms on students who are already socially stigmatized. Efforts to ameliorate paradigm dissonance tend to focus on changing student dispositions or lowering the stakes of failure. I instead propose wise interventions that include analyzing the systemic roots of stigmatized failure and making failure a more communal experience. I then briefly address the systemic transformations necessary to cultivate generative failure more broadly.
Al-Atabi, Mushtak. 2014. Think like an Engineer: Use Systematic Thinking to Solve Everyday Challenges and Unlock the Inherent Values in Them. CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform.
Banaji, Mahzarin R., and Anthony G. Greenwald. 2013. Blindspot: Hidden Biases of Good People. New York: Delacorte Press.
Bandura, Albert. 1997. Self-Efficacy: The Exercise of Control. New York: W. H. Freeman and Company. Barr, Robert B., and John Tagg. 1995. “From Teaching to Learning: A New Paradigm for Undergraduate Education.” Change 27: 12–25.
Bee, Vanessa A. 2018. “Innovation under Socialism.” Current Affairs 3, no. 4 (July/August): 47–51.
Brown, Peter C., Henry L. Roediger III, and Mark A. McDaniel. 2014. Make it Stick: The Science of Successful Learning. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Burnett, Bill, and Dave Evans. 2016. Designing Your Life: How to Build a Well-Lived, Joyful Life. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
Carey, Benedict. 2014. How We Learn: The Surprising Truth about When, Where, and Why It Happens. New York: Random House.
Carr, Allison. 2013. “In Support of Failure.” Composition Forum 27. https://compositionforum.com/issue/27/failure.php.
Chishti, Muzaffar, Sarah Pierce, and Jessica Bolter. 2017. “The Obama Record on Deportations: Deporter in Chief or Not? Policy Beat, January 26, 2017. https://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/obama-record-deportations-deporter-chief-or-not.
Cohen, Geoffrey, Claude M. Steele, and Lee D. Ross 1999. “The Mentor’s Dilemma: Providing Critical Feedback across the Racial Divide.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 25: 1302–18.
Covington, Martin V. 1984. “The Self-Worth Theory of Achievement Motivation: Findings and Implications." Elementary School Journal 85, no. 1: 4–20. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1001615?seq=1.
Cox, Rebecca. 2009. The College Fear Factor: How Students and Professor Misunderstand One Another. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Davidson, Cathy N. 2017. The New Education: How to Revolutionize the University to Prepare Students for a World in Flux. New York: Basic Books.
Dweck, Carol S. 2006. Mindset: The New Psychology of Success. New York: Ballantine Books.
Feigenbaum, Paul. Forthcoming. “Welcome to Failure Club: Supporting Intrinsic Motivation, Sort of, in College Writing.” Pedagogy: Critical Approaches to Teaching Literature, Language, Composition, and Culture.
Ferrandino, Joseph A. 2016. “Student Achievement in Undergraduate Statistics: The Potential Value of Allowing Failure.” Journal of the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning 16, no. 6: 1–18. https://doi.org/10.14434/josotl.v16i6.20261.
Field, Kelly. 2018. “A Third of Your Freshmen Disappear: How Can You Keep Them?” Chronicle of Higher Education, June 12, 2018. www.chronicle.com/article/A-Third-of-Your-Freshmen/243560.
Fitzpatrick, Kathleen. 2019. Generous Thinking: A Radical Approach to Saving the University. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.
Freire, Paolo. 1994. Pedagogy of Hope: Reliving the Pedagogy of the Oppressed. New York: Continuum.
Gerald, Casey. 2018. There Will Be No Miracles Here: A Memoir. New York: Riverhead Books.
Goffman, Erving. 1963. Stigma: Notes on the Management of a Spoiled Identity. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall. Hallmark, Tyler. 2018. “When ‘Failure is OK’ is Not OK.” Chronicle of Higher Education, February 11, 2018. https://www.chronicle.com/article/When-Failure-Is-OK-Is/242489.
Burger, Edward. 2012. “Teaching to Fail.” Inside Higher Ed, August 21, 2012. www.insidehighered.com/views/2012/08/21/essay-importance-teaching-failure. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167299258011
Coleman, Aaron R. 2020. “The Near-Certainty of a Black Depression.” Vox, May 6, 2020. https://www.vox.com/2020/5/6/21248330/coronavirus-black-americans-depression.
Edmondson, Amy C. 2011. “Strategies for Learning from Failure.” Harvard Business Review, April 2011. https://hbr.org/2011/04/strategies-for-learning-from-failure.
Fain, Paul. 2018. “Average Loan Debt for Graduates of Four-Year Colleges: $28,560.” Inside Higher Ed, September 20, 2018. https://www.insidehighered.com/quicktakes/2018/09/20/average-loan-debt-graduates-four- year-colleges-28650.
Hooks, Bell. 2003. Teaching Community: A Pedagogy of Hope. New York: Routledge.
Hyung-jung, Yun. 2012. “For ‘Losers,’ Korean Society is Unforgiving.” Hankyoreh, August 31, 2012. http://english.hani.co.kr/arti/english_edition/e_national/549615.html.
Inman, Joyce. 2018. “Breaking out of the Basic Writing Closet.” Pedagogy: Critical Approaches to Teaching Literature, Language, Composition, and Culture 18, no. 1: 1–23. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/683379.
Inoue, Asao B. 2014. “Theorizing Failure in US Writing Assessments.” Research in the Teaching of English 48, no. 3: 330–52. www.ncte.org/library/NCTEFiles/Resources/Journals/RTE/0483- feb2014/RTE0483Theorizing.pdf.
James, Sherman A. 1994. “John Henryism and the Health of African-Americans.” Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 18: 163–82.
Kapur, Manu. 2015. “Learning from Productive Failure.” Learning: Research and Practice 1, no. 15: 51–65. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/23735082.2015.1002195.
Kiernan, Paul. 2018. “Parents’ Jobs Increasingly Shape How Far Kids Get in Life.” Wall Street Journal, September 3, 2018. https://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2018/09/03/parents-jobs-increasingly-shape-how-far-kids-get- in-life/.
Kiracofe, Philip. 2012. “Failure Club.” Youtube, December 1, 2012. https://www.youtube.com/watchv=R8kvv2vLQTU.
Klosowksi, Thorin. 2017. “What the Best Commencement Speeches Teach Us about Failure.” Lifehacker, April 11, 2017. lifehacker.com/what-the-best-commencement-speeches-teach-us-about-fail-1794173713.
Kohn, Alfie. 2015. “The Perils of ‘Growth Mindset’ Education: Why We’re Trying to Fix Our Kids When We Should Be Fixing the System.” Salon, August 11, 2015. https://www.salon.com/2015/08/16/the_education_fad_thats_hurting_our_kids_what_you_need_to_know_about_growth_mindset_theory_and_the_harmful_lessons_it_imparts/.
Lang, James. 2013. Cheating Lessons: Learning from Academic Dishonesty. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Laymon, Kiese. 2018. Heavy: An American Memoir. New York: Scribner.
Lebron, Christopher J. 2018. ‘The Personal Cost of Black Success.” The Atlantic, November 2018. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/11/the-personal-cost-of-black-success/570820/.
Lemann, Nicholas. 1999. The Big Test: The Secret History of the American Meritocracy. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Littler, Jo. 2018. Against Meritocracy: Culture, Power and Myths of Mobility. London: Routledge. Losse, Kate. 2016.“The Art of Failing Upward.” New York Times, March 5, 2016 https://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/06/opinion/sunday/the-art-of-failing-upward.html.
Marano, Hara E. 2016. “Crisis U.” Psychology Today, June 10, 2016. https://www.psychologytoday.com/articles/201509/crisis-u.
McAlevey, Jane F. 2016. No Shortcuts: Organizing for Power. New York: Oxford University Press. Muller, Dalia A. 2019. “An Impossible Project.” Honors Today, 46: 6–9.
Purtill, Corinne. 2019. “The Museum of Failure’s Founder has a Failure of His Own: Personal Bankruptcy.” Quartz, February 2, 2019. https://qz.com/work/1538614/museum-of-failure-founder-files-bankruptcy- experiences-failure/.
Seifert, Timothy. 2004. “Understanding Student Motivation.” Educational Research 46, no. 2: 137–49. https://doi.org/10.1080/0013188042000222421.
Simmons, Rachel. 2018. Enough as She Is: How to Help Girls Move beyond Impossible Standards of Success to Live Healthy, Happy, and Fulfilling Lives. New York: Harper.
Standing, Guy. 2017. The Precariat: The New Dangerous Class. London: Bloomsbury.
Ibe, Peniel. 2020. “Trump’s Attacks on the Legal Immigration System Explained.” American Friends Service Committee, April 23, 2020. https://www.afsc.org/blogs/news-and-commentary/trumps-attacks-legal- immigration-system-explained.
Jack, Anthony A. 2019. The Privileged Poor: How Elite Colleges are Failing Disadvantaged Students. Cambridge:
Harvard University Press.
Murdock, Tamera B., and Eric M. Anderman. 2006. “Motivational Perspectives on Student Cheating: Toward an Integrated Model of Academic Dishonesty.” Educational Psychologist 41, no. 3: 129–45. http://dx.doi.org/10.1207/s15326985ep4103_1.
Soares, Joseph A. 2007. The Power of Privilege: Yale and America’s Elite Colleges. Palo Alto: Stanford University Press.
Steger, Isabella, and Sookyoung Lee. 2019. “South Korea’s Success-Obsessed Culture is Finally Reckoning with its Dark Side.” Quartz, November 14, 2019. https://qz.com/work/1714750/south-koreas-government-is- trying-to-teach-people-how-to-fail/.
Sternberg, Robert J. 2012. College Admissions for the 21st Century. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Stewart, Emily. 2020. “The American Unemployment System is Broken by Design.” Vox, May 13, 2020.
Stoller, Matt. 2017. “The Return of Monopoly.” The New Republic, July 13, 2017. https://newrepublic.com/article/143595/return-monopoly-amazon-rise-business-tycoon-white-house-democrats-return-party-trust-busting-roots.
Thompson, Derek. 2019. “Workism is Making Americans Miserable.” The Atlantic, February 24, 2019. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/02/religion-workism-making-americans-miserable/583441/.
Tough, Paul. 2019. The Years that Matter Most: How College Makes or Breaks Us. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
Twenge, Jean M. 2017. iGen: Why Today’s Super-Connected Kids are Growing Up Less Rebellious, More Tolerant, Less Happy—and Completely Unprepared for Adulthood—and What That Means for the Rest of Us. New York: Atria Books.
Verschelden, Cia. 2017. Bandwidth Recovery: Helping Students Reclaim Cognitive Resources Lost to Poverty, Racism, and Social Marginalization. Sterling: Stylus.
Webster, David, and Nicola Rivers. 2019. “Resisting Resilience: Disrupting Discourses of Self-Efficacy. Pedagogy, Culture & Society 27, no. 4: 523–35. https://doi.org/10.1080/14681366.2018.1534261.
Yeager, David S., Valerie Purdie-Vaughns, Julio Garcia, Nancy Apfel, Patti Brzustoski, Allison Master, William T. Hessert, Matthew E. Williams, and Geoffrey L. Cohen. 2014. “Breaking the Cycle of Mistrust: Wise Interventions to Provide Critical Feedback Across the Racial Divide.” Journal of Experimental Psychology 143, no. 2: 804–24. http://doi.org/10.1037/a0033906.
Wood, Jessica. 2017. “Why Finland Has a National Day of Failure.” The Culture Trip, October 3, 2017. https://theculturetrip.com/europe/finland/articles/why-finland-has-a-national-day-of-failure/.