Is it Too Optimistic to Assume Light Touch Interventions can Improve Educational Workers’ Wellbeing? Insights from a Field Randomized Control Trial in Canada
Keywords:
wellbeing, burnout, education, nudges, randomized controlled trial, schoolsAbstract
Educator wellbeing has broad implications for students and schools. Current approaches to address this problem are generally resource-intensive. This trial used novel nudges to increase wellbeing and decrease burnout among educators and other school-based faculty. We designed a light touch intervention where T1 received evidence-based wellbeing weekly text messages and T2 received weekly messages plus leadership endorsement emails. We evaluated this intervention in a large-scale three-arm RCT with participants (n=1,155) from K-12 schools in Manitoba, Alberta, and British Columbia. When compared to the control group, we saw no significant difference between the control group and T1 and T2 groups on burnout or wellbeing. The failure of these evidence-based text messages in increasing educators’ wellbeing and reducing their burnout highlights both the difficulty of addressing this problem and the importance of learning lessons from trials with null results to contribute to our knowledge base of improving educators’ wellbeing.
References
Berlyne, D. E. (1951). Attention, perception and behavior theory. Psychological Review, 58(2), 137–146. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0058364
Betsch, T., Fiedler, K., & Brinkmann, J. (1998). Behavioral routines in Decision making: The effects of novelty in task presentation and time pressure on routine maintenance and deviation. European Journal of Social Psychology, 28(6), 861–878. https://doi.org/10.1002/(sici)1099-0992(1998110)28:6<861::aid-ejsp899>3.0.co;2-d
Bowers, T., & McIver, M. (2000). Ill Health Retirement and Absenteeism Amongst Teachers. Nottingham: Department for Education and Employment, Report number RR235. Accessed March 15, 2017 at : http://dera.ioe.ac.uk/4471/1/RR235.pdf
Brazier, A., Larson, E., Xu, Y., Judah, G., Egan, M., Burd, H., & Darzi, A. (2022). ‘Dear Doctor’: a randomised controlled trial of a text message intervention to reduce burnout in trainee anaesthetists. Anaesthesia, 77(4), 405–415. https://doi.org/10.1111/anae.15643
Briner, R., & Dewberry, C. (2007). Faculty wellbeing is the Key to School Success. www.worklifesupport.com
Cann, R. (2019). The importance of teacher wellbeing. The Education Hub. https://theeducationhub.org.nz/the-importance-of-teacher-wellbeing/
Carolan, S., Harris, P. R., & Cavanagh, K. (2017). Improving employee well-being and effectiveness: systematic review and meta-analysis of web-based psychological interventions delivered in the workplace. Journal of medical Internet research, 19(7), e271.
Chambers, C. N. L., Frampton, C. M. A., Barclay, M., & McKee, M. (2016). Burnout prevalence in New Zealand’s public hospital senior medical workforce: a cross-sectional mixed methods study. BMJ Open, 6(11), e013947. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2016-013947
Chou, L. P., Li, C. Y., & Hu, S. C. (2014). Job stress and burnout in hospital employees: Comparisons of different medical professions in a regional hospital in Taiwan. BMJ Open, 4(2), e004185. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2013-004185
Collie, R. J., Shapka, J. D., & Perry, N. E. (2012). School climate and social–emotional learning: Predicting teacher stress, job satisfaction, and teaching efficacy. Journal of Educational Psychology, 104(4), 1189–1204. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0029356
Davis, J., & Wilson, S. M. (2000). Principals’ efforts to empower teachers: Effects on teacher motivation and job satisfaction and stress. The Clearing House, 73(6), 349–353.
De Nobile, J. (2008). Communication: Its importance for teacher well-being. Education Connect: Occasional Papers about Social and Emotional Wellbeing in Education, 13, 11–13.
Dolan, P., Hallsworth, M., Halpern, D., King, D., & Vlaev, I. (2010). Mindspace: Influencing behavior through public policy. http://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/sites/default/files/%0Dpublications/MINDSPACE.pdf
Dunford, B. B., Shipp, A. J., Boss, R. W., Angermeier, I., & Boss, A. D. (2012). Is burnout static or dynamic? A career transition perspective of employee burnout trajectories. Journal of Applied Psychology, 97(3), 637–650. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0027060
Fiorilli, C., de Stasio, S., Benevene, P., Iezzi, D. F., Pepe, A., & Albanese, O. (2015). Copenhagen Burnout Inventory (CBI): A validation study in an Italian teacher group. Testing, Psychometrics, Methodology in Applied Psychology, 22, 537–551. https://doi.org/10.4473/TPM22.4.7
Froese-Germain, B. (2014), Work-Life Balance and the Canadian Teaching Profession. Canadian Teachers’ Federation.
Harding, S., Kidger, J., Murphy, S., Araya, R., Campbell, R., Brockman, R., Grey, J., Bell, S., Evans, R., Tilling, K., Hollingworth, W., Ford, T., Gunnell, D., & Morris, R. (2019, January 1). Is teachers' mental health and wellbeing associated with students' mental health and wellbeing? Journal of affective disorders, 242, 180–187.
Hastings, R. P., & Bham, M. S. (2003). The relationship between student behaviour patterns and teacher burnout. School psychology international, 24(1), 115–127.
Helios, M., & Rosario, D. (2020). Package “pwr” Title Basic Functions for Power Analysis. https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/pwr/pwr.pdf
Henderson, M., Harvey, S. B., Øverland, S., Mykletun, A., & Hotopf, M. (2011). Work and common psychiatric disorders. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 104(5), 198–207.
Huppert, F., & Ruggeri, K. (2018). Policy Challenges: Well-being as a priority in public mental health. Oxford Textbook of Public Mental Health, 30, 131–140.
Iancu, A. E., Rusu, A., Măroiu, C., Păcurar, R., & Maricuțoiu, L. P. (2018). The effectiveness of interventions aimed at reducing teacher burnout: A meta-analysis. Educational psychology review, 30(2), 373–396.
Ingersoll, R., & May, H. (2011). Recruitment, Retention and the Minority Teacher Shortage. Consortium for Policy Research in Education. CPRE Research Report.
Jennings, P. A., & Greenberg, M. T. (2009). The prosocial classroom: Teacher social and emotional competence in relation to student and classroom outcomes. Review of educational research, 79(1), 491-525.
Kidger, J., Stone, T., Tilling, K., Brockman, R., Campbell, R., Ford, T., … Gunnell, D. (2016). A pilot cluster randomised controlled trial of a support and training intervention to improve the mental health of secondary school teachers and students – the WISE (Wellbeing in Secondary Education) study. BMC Public Health, 16(1), 1060. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-016-3737-y
Klingbeil, D. A., & Renshaw, T. L. (2018). Mindfulness-based interventions for teachers: A meta-analysis of the emerging evidence base. School Psychology Quarterly, 33(4), 501–511.
Kristensen, T. S., Borritz, M., Villadsen, E., & Christensen, K. B. (2005). The Copenhagen Burnout Inventory: A new tool for the assessment of burnout. Work & Stress, 19(3), 192–207. https://doi.org/10.1080/02678370500297720
Linos, E., Ruffini, K., & Wilcoxen, S. (2019). Reducing Burnout for 911 Dispatchers and Call Takers: A Field Experiment. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Reducing-Burnout-for-911-Dispatchers-and-Call-A-Linos-Ruffini/6e45d76b28bdd8afa22c457a1845617262de5db6?p2df
Loukas, A., & Murphy, J. L. (2007). Middle school student perceptions of school climate: Examining protective functions on subsequent adjustment problems. Journal of school psychology, 45(3), 293–309.
Luhmann, M., & Intelisano, S. (2018). Hedonic Adaptation and the Set Point for Subjective Well-Being. Handbook of Well-Being.
Melchior, M., Caspi, A., Milne, B. J., Danese, A., Poulton, R., & Moffitt, T. E. (2007). Work stress precipitates depression and anxiety in young, working women and men. Psychological medicine, 37(8), 1119–1129.
Milfont, T. L., Denny, S., Ameratunga, S., Robinson, E., & Merry, S. (2008). Burnout and wellbeing: Testing the Copenhagen burnout inventory in New Zealand teachers. Social Indicators Research, 89(1), 169–177. https://doi.org/10.1007/S11205-007-9229-9
Miller, R. (2012). Teacher Absence as a Leading Indicator of Student Achievement New National Data Offer Opportunity to Examine Cost of Teacher Absence Relative to Learning Loss.
Miller, R. T., Murnane, R. J., & Willett, J. B. (2008). Do teacher absences impact student achievement? Longitudinal evidence from one urban school district. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 30(2), 181–200.
Naghieh, A., Montgomery, P., Bonell, C. P., Thompson, M., & Aber, J. L. (2015). Organisational interventions for improving wellbeing and reducing work‐related stress in teachers. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, (4), CD010306.
Ng Fat, L., Scholes, S., Boniface, S., Mindell, J., & Stewart-Brown, S. (2017). Evaluating and establishing national norms for mental wellbeing using the short Warwick–Edinburgh Mental Well-being Scale (SWEMWBS): Findings from the Health Survey for England. Quality of Life Research, 26(5), 1129–1144. https://doi.org/doi: 10.1007/s11136-016- 1454-8
Noble, T., & McGrath, H. (2012). Wellbeing and resilience in young people and the role of positive relationships. In Positive relationships (pp. 17-33). Springer, Dordrecht.
O’Connor, K. E. (2008). “You choose to care”: Teachers, emotions and professional identity. Teaching and teacher education, 24(1), 117–126.
Parr, J. M., Pinto, N., Hanson, M., Meehan, A., & Moore, P. T. (2016). Medical graduates, tertiary hospitals, and burnout: A longitudinal cohort study. The Ochsner Journal, 16(1), 22–26.
Pas, E. T., Bradshaw, C. P., & Hershfeldt, P. A. (2012). Teacher-and school-level predictors of teacher efficacy and burnout: Identifying potential areas for support. Journal of school Psychology, 50(1), 129–145.
Roffey, S. (2012). Pupil wellbeing—Teacher wellbeing: Two sides of the same coin?, Educational and Child Psychology, 29(4), 8. https://www.sueroffey.com/wp-content/uploads/import/32-Roffey ECP29-4.pdf
Sänger, J., Bechtold, L., Schoofs, D., Blaszkewicz, M., & Wascher, E. (2014). The influence of acute stress on attention mechanisms and its electrophysiological correlates. Frontiers in behavioral neuroscience, 8, 353.
Shah, M. (2012). The importance and benefits of teacher collegiality in schools–A literature review. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 46, 1242–1246.
Sheldon, K. M., & Yu, S. (2021). Methods of gratitude expression and their effects upon well-being: Texting may be just as rewarding as and less risky than face-to-face. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 17(5), 690–700. https://doi.org/10.1080/17439760.2021.1913639
Sisask, M., Värnik, P., Värnik, A., Apter, A., Balazs, J., Balint, M., Bobes, J., Brunner, R., Corcoran, P., Cosman, D., Feldman, D., Haring, C., Kahn, J. P., Poštuvan, V., Tubiana, A., Sarchiapone, M., Wasserman, C., Carli, V., Hoven, C. W., & Wasserman, D. (2013). Teacher satisfaction with school and psychological well-being affects their readiness to help children with mental health problems. Health Education Journal, 73(4), 382–393. https://doi.org/10.1177/0017896913485742
Skaalvik, E. M., & Skaalvik, S. (2009). Does school context matter? Relations with teacher burnout and job satisfaction. Teaching and teacher education, 25(3), 518–524.
Taylor, D. L., & Tashakkori, A. (1995). Decision participation and school climate as predictors of job satisfaction and teachers' sense of efficacy. The Journal of experimental education, 63(3), 217–230.
Van Dierendonck, D., Haynes, C., Borrill, C., & Stride, C. (2004). Leadership behavior and subordinate well-being. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 9(2), 165–175. https://doi.org/10.1037/1076-8998.9.2.165
Woodend, A., Schölmerich, V., & Denktas, S. (2015). “Nudges” to prevent behavioral risk factors associated with Major Depressive Disorder, American journal of public health, 105(11), 2318–21.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Emily E. Larson, Dr. Yihan Xu, Dr. Philip Oreopoulous, Sasha Tregebov
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
a. Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
b. Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
c. Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work.
