Single-Sex schooling at an Elite Independent School: A Multi-Methods Case Study

Authors

  • Daniel B. Robinson St. Francis Xavier University
  • Gregory R. L. Hadley St. Francis Xavier University
  • Jennifer Mitton St. Francis Xavier University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.55016/ojs/ajer.v70i1.76625

Abstract

This article focuses upon the milieu of single-sex schooling within an elite independent school in a Canadian urban centre. This research served as an exploratory and critical examination of single-sex schooling in a specific context, and considered its relevance, pedagogical effectiveness, and ability to meet its purported goals. Using an interpretative methodological framework, and employing a multi-methods case study design, the purpose of this research was to investigate the strengths, limitations, and possibilities of single-sex schooling in a particular educational context as informed by its students, parents of students, graduates, and teachers. We found little evidence to support the idea that single-sex schooling overwhelmingly impacted student academic or social development. Implications for practice at schools offering single-sex schooling are addressed and focus upon the importance of gender-inclusive schooling; the school as the key, rather than the school’s single-sex classes; and addressing boys’ behaviour.

Key words: single-sex, gender, schooling, independent school, private school

Cet article se penche sur un milieu de scolarisation non mixte au sein d’une école privée élitiste d’un centre urbain canadien. Cette recherche a permis d’examiner de façon exploratoire et critique la scolarisation non mixte dans un contexte précis, ainsi que sa pertinence, son efficacité pédagogique et sa capacité à atteindre les objectifs escomptés. Par l’utilisation d’un cadre méthodologique interprétatif et le recours à une étude de cas multimodale, cette recherche poursuivait l’objectif d’examiner les forces, les limites et les possibilités de l’enseignement en milieu non mixte, dans un contexte éducatif particulier, comme le décrivent les élèves, leurs parents, les diplômés et les enseignants. À la suite de cet examen, peu de preuves viennent soutenir l’idée que la scolarisation en milieu non mixte a un impact considérable sur le développement scolaire et social des élèves. L’article traite des implications pour la pratique dans les écoles offrant une scolarisation non mixte et se concentre sur l’importance d’une scolarisation inclusive des genres, sur l’école comme étant la clé plutôt que les classes non mixtes, et à considérer le comportement des garçons.

Mots clés : non mixte, genre, scolarisation, école indépendante, école privée

Author Biographies

Daniel B. Robinson, St. Francis Xavier University

Daniel B. Robinson, PhD is a Professor and Coordinator of the PhD in Educational Studies Program, as well as Chair of the Department of Curriculum and Leadership, at St. Francis Xavier University. He teaches undergraduate courses in elementary physical and health education curriculum and instruction. He also teaches graduate courses in critical research literacy, contemporary research in curriculum and instruction, administration of inclusive schools, curriculum theory, and school and teaching effectiveness. Dr. Robinson’s research focuses on physical literacy, sport and (dis)ability, culturally responsive physical education, gender and racialized minorities, service learning, and in-school health promotion programming.

Gregory R. L. Hadley, St. Francis Xavier University

Dr. Gregory R. L. Hadley is an Assistant Professor and Chair of Entrepreneurship Education with the Faculty of Education at St. Francis Xavier University. His primary area of interest is in entrepreneurship education, where he actively researches how school can support the development of entrepreneurial youth. Prior to his current position, he was a high school teacher in rural Nova Scotia, Canada.

 

Jennifer Mitton, St. Francis Xavier University

Dr. Jennifer Mitton is a Professor of secondary literacy and qualitative research methods in the Faculty of Education at St. Francis Xavier University in Nova Scotia. Prior to university teaching, she taught in secondary schools in New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and Turkey. Her research interests include adolescent literacies, pre-service teachers and early career teachers, and teacher pedagogy related to culturally responsive beliefs and instruction.

Published

2024-03-13

How to Cite

Robinson, D. B., Hadley, G. R. L., & Mitton, J. (2024). Single-Sex schooling at an Elite Independent School: A Multi-Methods Case Study . Alberta Journal of Educational Research, 70(1), 37–59. https://doi.org/10.55016/ojs/ajer.v70i1.76625

Issue

Section

ARTICLES