Has the City-Rural Tax Base and Land-Use Balance Changed in Alberta? Explorations into the Distribution of Equalized Property Assessments Among Municipality Classes

Auteurs-es

  • Melville McMillan University of Alberta

DOI :

https://doi.org/10.11575/sppp.v11i0.43330

Résumé

Alberta ended its regional planning commissions in 1996. They were replaced by voluntary inter-municipal negotiation, but this has raised concerns about adverse effects on land use. Pressure to terminate the commissions came largely from the rural municipalities. Some of them felt the commissions retarded their economic development. They believed that in a less restrictive planning environment, they would be able to attract a greater share of development, especially business. This study assesses the consequences of that change. Alberta’s rapid growth over much of the post-1995 period affords an exceptional opportunity to search for noticeable changes in the urban-rural tax base and land-use patterns and balance.


Municipal tax base is measured, and land use reflected, by property values. Those values are taken to be the provincially determined equalized assessments used for property tax purposes. Fortunately, these provide a reliable and consistent measure of property values across municipalities and over time for properties of different kinds. For the types of properties of prime interest for this analysis, residential and unregulated business property, equalized assessments approximate 100 per cent of market value. Residential property represents over 60 per cent of total provincial equalized assessments and business property about 20 per cent. In cities, the percentages are 70 per cent and 24 per cent; residential and business properties represent almost all the taxable property. The focus of the analysis is whether, during the past two decades, the shares of residential and/or business property have shifted from cities to rural municipalities.

 


The possibility of shifting city-rural tax base/land-use patterns is explored from four perspectives. This report examines trends in the distribution of residential and business equalized assessments among the types of municipalities in the province. To obtain a better perspective in specific cases, the city-rural split of assessments is reported for the Edmonton and Calgary metropolitan areas and nine cities between 1997 and 2014. Examining the movements in the ratios of business to residential assessments of 31 city and rural municipalities provides further insight. The final approach is to simply review changes in the location of population and dwellings between cities and rural areas.

 

There has been no notable or general shift of land development away from cities and to rural areas. Despite the rapid growth and the devolved planning environment, the cityversus-rural distribution of tax base and land use has, overall, been remarkably constant although development was definitely not uniform across Alberta cities. If anything, the cities’ shares of residential development may have increased while their shares of business development have been more uneven. For both types of property, however, the development patterns have varied across both city and rural municipalities. Concern that the changed planning environment might have shifted property development towards the rural municipalities does not appear to have been justified. Whether this development met other planning criteria is not explored here. This analysis encourages more detailed investigations using alternative indicators.

Références

Agrawal, Sandeep. 2016. “Urban, Suburban and Wet Growth in Alberta.” Alberta Land Institute,

University of Alberta. May. Available at http://www.albertalandinstitute.ca/public/download/

documents/34087

Alberta Association of Municipal Districts and Counties and Alberta Urban Municipalities Association.

Municipal Attitudes Towards Regional Planning in Alberta. October.

Alberta Municipal Affairs, Equalized Assessment Reports (annual). Available at

http://www.municipalaffairs.alberta.ca/mc_property_assessment_and_taxation_reports

Alberta Municipal Affairs, Guide to Equalized Assessment in Alberta. Available at

http://www.municipalaffairs.alberta.ca/documents/as/Guide_to_Equalized_Assessment.pdf

Alberta Municipal Affairs, Guide to Property Assessment and Taxation in Alberta. Available at

http://www.municipalaffairs.alberta.ca/documents/as/AB_GuidePtyAssmt_finrev.pdf

Alberta Municipal Affairs, Land Use Policies. Available at http://www.municipalaffairs.alberta.ca/

documents/ms/landusepoliciesmga.pdf

Alberta Municipal Affairs, Legislative Framework. Available at http://www.municipalaffairs.alberta.ca/

documents/ms/THE_LEGISLATIVE_FRAMEWORK_2012-08_Version.pdf

Alberta Municipal Affairs, Maps and Statistics. Available at http://www.municipalaffairs.alberta.ca/

mc_maps_statistics

Alberta Municipal Affairs. 2001. Minister’s Guidelines for the Assessment of Farmland, Linear

Property, Machinery and Equipment, Railway. Available at http://www.municipalaffairs.alberta.ca/

documents/as/01MinistersGuidelinesAssessmentFLPMR.pdf

Alberta Municipal Affairs, Municipal Financial and Statistical Data. Available at http://www.

municipalaffairs.alberta.ca/municipal_financial_statistical_data.

Alberta Professional Planners Institute. 2014. Municipal Government Act Review: Recommendations for

Proposed Amendment to the Municipal Government Act. June.

Beesley, Kenneth B. 2010. The Rural-Urban Fringe in Canada: Conflict and Controversy. Brandon, MB:

Rural Development Institute, Brandon University.

Calgary Regional Partnership. Available at http://calgaryregion.ca/crp/calgary-regional-partnership/

about/overview.html

Capital Region Board. Available at http://capitalregionboard.ab.ca/

Climenhaga, David J. 1997. “The Death and Life of Regional Planning in the Calgary Area,” Master’s

Thesis, School of Journalism, University of Calgary.

Conger, Brian W., Bev Dahlby and Melville L. McMillan. 2016. Municipal Revenue Generation

and Development in the Calgary and Edmonton Metropolitan Regions, School of Public Policy,

University of Calgary.

Dragushan, Graham N.G. 1979. “Regional Planning in Alberta: The Evolution of Alberta’s System of

Regional Planning Commissions.” Master’s Thesis, School of Community and Regional Planning,

University of British Columbia.

Ghitter, Geoff and Alan Smart. 2009. “Mad Cows, Regional Governance and Urban Sprawl,” Urban

Affairs Review, 44(#5), May: 617-644.

Haarsma, D. and Feng Qiu. 2017. “Assessing Neighbor and Population Growth Influences on Agriculture

Land Conversion,” Applied Spatial Analysis and Policy, 10(1) March: 21-41.

Haarsma, Darren, Angela Bentley, Claire Doll, Scott Jeffrey, and Feng Qiu. 2014. “Agricultural Land

Conversion and Fragmentation in Alberta: A Review of Land Cover Patterns 2000-2012 and Land

Use Policy.” The Alberta Land Institute, University of Alberta. August. Available at http://www.

albertalandinstitute.ca/public/download/documents/10440

LeSage, Edward C. Jr. and Melville L. McMillan. 2010. “Alberta Municipal Systems Overview Update,”

Information Bulletin 135, Western Centre for Economic Research, University of Alberta. January.

Masson, Jack and Edward C. LeSage Jr. 1994. Alberta’s Local Governments: Politics and Democracy,

Edmonton: University of Alberta Press.

Masuda, Jeffrey R. and Theresa Garvin. 2008. “Whose Heartland?: The Politics of Place in a RuralUrban

Interface,” Journal of Rural Sociology, 24(1), January: 112-123.

McMillan, Melville and Bev Dahlby. 2014. Do Municipal Governments Need More Tax Powers?

A Background Paper on Municipal Finance in Alberta. School of Public Policy, University of

Calgary. November.

Taylor, Zack, Marcy Burchfield, and Anna Kramer. 2014. Alberta Cities at the Crossroads: Urban

Development Challenges and Opportunities in Historical and Comparative Perspective, SPP

Research Papers, School of Public Policy, University of Calgary. May.

Téléchargements

Publié-e

2018-02-05

Numéro

Rubrique

Research Papers